Log in

List of MTG Engines

Here's a list of MTG Engines:

Contents

Basic Features

Name DesktopOS MobileOS Language Last Release Release Schedule AI* Card Count*
Forge Any (Java) N/A Java 2012-08-03 (1.2.11) 3-4 Weeks Simple 11034
Incantus Any (Python)  ? Python 2012-05-23 (0.7.1c) 1-68 Weeks None 2583+
MAGE Any (Java)  ? Java 2012-07-02 (0.8.7) 5-15 Weeks Mad 4000+
BotArena Windows  ? C++ 2012-07-07 (1.39.1) ~4-6 Weeks Good* 9500+
Magarena Any (Java)  ? Java 2012-07-29 (1.28) ~4-5 Weeks Minimax/Monte Carlo 2373
Wagic Any PSP,Android,iOS C++ (0.18.6)  ? Simple 9000+
Manalink 3.0 Windows None ASM / C++ 2012-07-15 (Kamigawa Block) 4 Weeks Simple 5000+

Comparable Features

Name Undo Multiplayer* Network Play* "Quest" Mode Draft Sealed Card Scripting
Forge Limited (Costs) No No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Incantus None No Yes No No No Yes
MAGE Limited (Costs) Yes Yes No Yes Yes No
BotArena Limited (Basics) No Yes No No Yes No
Magarena Yes No No No No No Yes
Wagic  ? No No Yes No No Yes
Manalink 3.0 No Not working Not working Yes Yes Yes No

Additional Features

Name Standard Commander Planechase Vanguard Archenemy Ante
Forge 95+% No No No No Yes
Incantus  ??% No No No No No
MAGE 100% No No No No No
BotArena 85% Yes Yes Yes Yes  ?
Magarena 51% No No No No No
Wagic  ??%  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?

Images

Name Pictures Folder Structure Naming Convention Crops Full Uniques*
Forge Yes Set-per-folder slightlymagic No Yes Yes
Incantus Yes All in one folder WotC website* No Yes No
MAGE  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?
BotArena Yes Set-per-folder slightlymagic No Yes Yes
Magarena  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?  ?
Wagic No? - - - - -

Usage

Here are some brief instructions on how to add Engines to the above tables. Please let me know (friarsol) if you have difficulties with the instructions, and I'll try to clarify them.

Adding an Engine

Copy the format provided by one of the other Engines already on the list.

For example, on the first table, copy the following (from the wiki code):

|-
| [http://www.slightlymagic.net/forum/viewforum.php?f=26 Forge] || Any (Java) || N/A || Java || 2012-08-03 [http://www.slightlymagic.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=7738 (1.2.11)] || 3-4 Weeks || Simple || 11034 

and paste it below the last line that starts an Engine table row, just before the

|}

and then fill in the appropriate data, making sure to leave spaces in between the || symbol

Each table has slightly different column length, so make sure to grab your sample table row from the right table before adding.

Adding new Columns

If you'd like to add a new Column, I'd recommend adding at the end of an existing table. The trick here is to make sure you provide phantom data cells for every other engine that exists. Unless you don't mind hitting the preview button a lot, feel free to make suggestions and I can add them in if they seem like a reasonable comparison.

Notes

  • For AI column, please give a short description that makes a touch of senseabotu how the AI works (AI/Simple State machine etc), if we need to expand below with a longer description we can do that later.
  • Card Count: There are about 13000 Distinct Mtg Cards ever printed.
  • Multiplayer means more than 2 Players. Network Play means More than 1 Human.
  • BotArena AI: FranAvalon says: I dont know what we can put here, but if we compared BA's AI with the other.... At least BA's AI can win a lot of games playing as a real player, instead lose the games by yourself because you are mana flooding, mana screw. Also, which AI can win you on second turn? ;D.) Basically, AI is our main attraction
  • Image Uniques: This basically allows for cards which have more than one image in each set to be displayed in it's different forms. This was in effect for a few sets like Fallen Empires and Alliances. This is also the case for most basic lands.
  • Incantus downloads card images from the WotC website into a card_images.db, but it can also read images from the /data/cardimg/ folder as long as they use the same format, i.e. the name of the card with spaces turned into underscores and commas stripped out.