Collectible Card Game Headquarters

I just bought an Xbox 360 controller and when I try to create a multiplayer local game, DOTP crashes. I've checked my drivers and the settings in game and no luck. Any ideas?

Nevermind. I figured it out. It seems that the controller only works if I initiate a 2HG or F4A game starting from the single player menu. If I do multiplayer anything (even without the controller), it crashes.