[fixed/closed]Hunter's Insight & Hunter's Prowess + trample

[Nexhro]

Describe the Bug:
When a creature targetted by Hunter's Insight deals combat damage to a player, its controller doesn't get to draw any cards.

Which card did behave improperly ?
Hunter's Insight

Which update are you using?(date,name)Which type(Duel,Gauntlet,Sealed Deck)
CIA v2, Duel

What exactly should be the correct behavior/interaction ?
Whenever a creature targetted by Hunter's Insight deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, its controller draws that many cards.

Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
-

Edit1: confirmed by BAgate; Edit2: changed thread title to match new report guidelines

[Korath]

Works for me.

[Korath]

(Still works for me.)

[Nexhro]

Still doesn't seem to work with trample damage.

seems similiar to the Hunter's Prowess bug [see screenshots.)

On another occasion, Garruk's Companion blocked by a 2/1 and targetted by Hunter's Insight didn't draw any cards. That was like 10 mins ago.

[BAgate]

Confirmed as to trample. When trample damage is dealt it appears that you draw cards equal to trample damage + creature's power (same with Hunter's Prowess). I remember seeing something similar before, but I can't remember where.

[Korath]

Only when it's both trample damage and the creature is destroyed at the same time - the engine apparently removes destroyed creatures from play before applying trample damage. The same will happen for anything else triggering on dealing damage to a player, whether it's the creature itself or something attached to it that triggers. sub_4B23C0() is at fault, same as for the trample/lifelink bug.

event trace | Open

EVENT_PHASE_CHANGED
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_PREVENT_DAMAGE aff:0/13 Damage to Balduvian Bears
EVENT_PREVENT_DAMAGE aff:1/9 Damage to Garruk's Companion
EVENT_DAMAGE_PREVENTION aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_DEAL_DAMAGE aff:0/13 Damage to Balduvian Bears
EVENT_DEAL_DAMAGE aff:1/9 Damage to Garruk's Companion
TRIGGER_DEAL_DAMAGE cause:0/11 Garruk's Companion
EVENT_GRAVEYARD_FROM_PLAY aff:0/13 Damage to Balduvian Bears
EVENT_GRAVEYARD_FROM_PLAY aff:1/9 Damage to Garruk's Companion
TRIGGER_GRAVEYARD_ORDER cause:0/11 Garruk's Companion
TRIGGER_LEAVE_PLAY cause:0/11 Garruk's Companion
EVENT_GRAVEYARD_FROM_PLAY aff:0/12 effect:Hunter's Insight
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:1/8 Balduvian Bears
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:1/8 Balduvian Bears
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:1/8 Balduvian Bears
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_TOUGHNESS aff:1/8 Balduvian Bears
EVENT_POWER aff:1/8 Balduvian Bears
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
TRIGGER_GRAVEYARD_ORDER cause:0/11 Air Elemental
TRIGGER_LEAVE_PLAY cause:1/8 Balduvian Bears
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
TRIGGER_GRAVEYARD_ORDER cause:0/11 Air Elemental
TRIGGER_GRAVEYARD_FROM_PLAY cause:0/11 Air Elemental
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_PREVENT_DAMAGE aff:1/10 Trample Damage
EVENT_DAMAGE_PREVENTION aff:1/10 Trample Damage
EVENT_DEAL_DAMAGE aff:1/10 Trample Damage
TRIGGER_DEAL_DAMAGE cause:0/11 Air Elemental
EVENT_GRAVEYARD_FROM_PLAY aff:1/10 Trample Damage
TRIGGER_END_COMBAT cause:0/11 Air Elemental
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:0/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_SET_COLOR aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_CHANGE_TYPE aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_ABILITIES aff:1/7 Rules Engine
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest
EVENT_PHASE_CHANGED
EVENT_COUNT_MANA aff:0/1 Forest

The Hunter's Prowess bug miscounting damage dealt is unrelated (though Hunter's Prowess also has this one, and Hunter's Insight has that one) and a lot more tractable.

[Gargaroz]

Using a non-attached legacy solves the problem, it's a bit more confusing but oh well...
Hunter's insight fixed in 434f076 (but only the bug about not drawing if a creature with trample dies in combat).
Hunter's Prowess fixed in 0d953b8 (same as above).

[Nexhro]

Both cards work properly as of CoRM15 mini2.