[fixed/closed]Tainted Specter total mess
Posted: 21 Nov 2014, 14:35Describe the Bug:
1) When Tainted Specter's activated ability is activated, its controller gets to choose between discarding the "chosen card" or putting it on top, regardless of the targeted player.
2) When the ability is activated for the first time after starting Manalink, the following error message is prompted after a player has been targeted:
This doesn't seem to occur when activating the ability during upkeeps (which shouldn't be possible anyways, see #7).
3) When the discard option is chosen for the first time after starting Manalink, the following error message is prompted:
followed by this error message:
5) Choosing "discard" always results in the top card of Specter's controller's library being put into that player's graveyard, regardless of which player has been targeted. Neither player discards a card, but damage is dealt to creatures as though they did.
6) Choosing "put on top" always results in Specter's controller's library vanishing, regardless of which player has been targeted. According to Pull from Eternity, it is not exiled. Neither player puts a card on top of his/her library.
7) The ability can be activated at instant speed.
Which card did behave improperly ?
Tainted Specter
Which update are you using?(date,name)Which type(Duel,Gauntlet,Sealed Deck)
KOT, duel
What exactly should be the correct behavior/interaction ?
Tainted Specter
Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
-
1) When Tainted Specter's activated ability is activated, its controller gets to choose between discarding the "chosen card" or putting it on top, regardless of the targeted player.
2) When the ability is activated for the first time after starting Manalink, the following error message is prompted after a player has been targeted:
followed by this dump:Wrong parameters at address 0x410fe9
eax = 0x1
ecx = 0xffffffff
- activation dump | Open
This doesn't seem to occur when activating the ability during upkeeps (which shouldn't be possible anyways, see #7).
3) When the discard option is chosen for the first time after starting Manalink, the following error message is prompted:
followed by this dump:Wrong parameters at address 0x435b62
eax = 0x1
ecx = 0xffffffff
- discard dump | Open
followed by this error message:
4) The stack window displays the targeted player at first, but switches to displaying a creature on the battlefield once a mode has been chosen.bad parameters at address: 0x433829
eax = 0x1
ecx = 0xffffffff
5) Choosing "discard" always results in the top card of Specter's controller's library being put into that player's graveyard, regardless of which player has been targeted. Neither player discards a card, but damage is dealt to creatures as though they did.
6) Choosing "put on top" always results in Specter's controller's library vanishing, regardless of which player has been targeted. According to Pull from Eternity, it is not exiled. Neither player puts a card on top of his/her library.
7) The ability can be activated at instant speed.
Which card did behave improperly ?
Tainted Specter
Which update are you using?(date,name)Which type(Duel,Gauntlet,Sealed Deck)
KOT, duel
What exactly should be the correct behavior/interaction ?
Tainted Specter
Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
-