[Fixed] Bug Archive

[Salbei]

This Topic contains "fixed" Bugs.
---

Describe the Bug:
An animated Darksteel Citadel by Tezzeret Agent of Bolas is no more indestructible.
Salbei->> Darksteel Citadel dies to combat damage, it should be indestructible.

Which card did behave improperly ?
Darksteel Citadel

Which Version did you use ? (Constructed, Limited)
Constructed

What exactly should be the correct behaviour/interaction ?
Darksteel Citadel is indestructible. When it gets animated by Tezzeret it should turn from a indestructible Land into a indestructible Creature.
Salbei>> combat damage should not "destroy" a animated Darksteel Citadel.

Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
Maybe other indestructible Cards ( Darksteel Ingot ).


--> Edit by Salbei
Please add a Savegame !
-> Edit by Salbei
Unconfirmed after testing. Please upload a savegame where the bug can be reproduced.
-> Edit by Salbei
Confirmed after testing, use the Savegame posted by stassy.
sticky for 60 days or until fixed.

[Salbei]

Just created a savegame and tried this (attached).
I animate Darksteel Citadel with Tez and tried to Dark Banishing it.
The Darksteel Citadel survived !

So i can not confirm this.

[Salbei]

Describe the Bug:
I was playing EDH and the AI had Elspeth Tirel in play. I attacked and wasn't offered the possibility to attack the planeswalker.

Which card did behave improperly ?
Elspeth Tirel

Which Version did you use ? (Constructed, Limited)
Constructed

What exactly should be the correct behaviour/interaction ?
During the attack you should be offered the chance to attack the planeswalker or the AI.

Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
None that I can think of.

//edit by Salbei
Confirmed the Bug
Sticky for 60 days or until fixed
>>edit by Salbei
fixed, unsticky

[Salbei]

Savegame please !
I remember that bug too. Happened to me as well.

//attached a savegame!
Confirmed

[aww1979]

Maybe it's only combat damage that's the problem?

[aww1979]

Oh yeah, now that you mention this, I remember in one of the planeswalker decimation challenge rounds that I couldn't ever attack any of the planeswalkers. I'm betting it was the elspeth/jace round. I do remember in that case that I couldn't attack ANY planeswalker, not just that one.

[Salbei]

Then maybe he should have written that
Just kidding.

To fix bugs you first have to re-create them. This is where a savegame comes in handy.

No Savegame - No fix ^^

Unless anyone could provide a savegame this will remain [unconfirmed].

[aww1979]

Describe the Bug:
AI imprinted a Juggernaut onto Chrome Mox, which is not allowed. (Chrome Mox says you may not imprint artifacts or lands onto it)

Which card did behave improperly ?
Chrome Mox

Which Version did you use ? (Constructed, Limited)
Constructed (Challenge Mode: Enchanted Evening)

What exactly should be the correct behaviour/interaction ?
Chrome Mox should not be able to imprint artifacts (in this case a Juggernaut)

Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
Other stuff with imprint restrictions maybe, though I haven't seen evidence of it

>>Edit by Salbei
Confirmed, sticky for 60 days or until fixed.
>>Edit by Salbei
Fixed by Gargaroz, unsticky.

[Salbei]

Thanks for the "correct" report!
Really don´t want to make reporting harder than necessary for anyone to, but using a "template" like this is making it a lot easier to fetch the crucial information needed.

Had a bit trouble to "see" the imprinted card.
The imprint did not show up somehow.
Also i could not use debug mode to see the opponents hand (must be the Challenges "fault").
Re-created the scenario and could confirm the bug though.Nice catch!

Confirmed

[Salbei]

(reporting jatill bug report from old bug thread)

Describe the Bug:
If you tap Raging Ravine for R, he gets the triggered ability. The if you untap it and attack, it gets 2 counters (the trigger ability from tapping for mana will stack with the trigger ability from attacking which).

Which card did behave improperly ?
Raging Ravine

Which Version did you use ?
Constructed

What exactly should be the correct behaviour/interaction ?
Raging Ravine should not trigger ability when tapped for mana

>>edit by Salbei
Confirmed, sticky for 60 days or until fixed.
>>edit by Salbei
fixed, unsticky

[Salbei]

This also randomly happens with Kjeldoran Outpost if i remember right.

Just tested your savegame.
Whenever you tap the card it gets a "Attack Pump" legacy text.
However i could not check if any +1/+1 counters get placed on it in that savegame (simply could not pay the activation cost).

Just tried to re-create it (just played 40 Raging Ravine)
Savegame is attached. The same behavior can be observed.
However beside the incorrect Legacy effect i could not reproduce the +1/+1 counter gain.
Savegame is attached.

I know this bug exists, but i cannot reproduce it somehow.
The wrong legacy effect (when tapped for mana) is reproduce-able .
confirmed

[aww1979]

Describe the Bug:
When I had 2x Enchantress's Presence and Sigil of the Empty Throne all in play and cast an enchantment, I got an angel but did not draw two cards. Before the sigil was in play, I was drawing 2 cards each time I cast an enchantment as I should. After the sigil was in play, the EPs 'shut off'.

Which card did behave improperly ?
Sigil of the Empty Throne (though I suppose it could've been the EPs causing the trouble, but they were working fine until the Sigil was in play, so I'm guessing it's the culprit)

Which Version did you use ? (Constructed, Limited)
Constructed (Challenge mode: Enchanted Evening)

What exactly should be the correct behaviour/interaction ?
I should have drawn 2 cards AND gotten an angel token, not just the angel token

Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
Potentially anything where triggers from different cards trigger on the same event. ex: different landfall cards, stuff like Quirion Dryad + Kraken's Eye, etc

>>edit by Salbei
semi-confirmed, savegame is corrupted.
>>edit by Salbei
confirmed, use stassy´s savegame.
sticky for 60 days or until fixed.
>>edit by Salbei
fixed, unsticky

[aww1979]

I saw the colourless stripe on the Chrome Mox, and then checked the removed from game pile to find the Juggernaut there. It's possible that since the savegame reverts to the beginning of the turn that it chose not to do the same thing for you. A few turns later, it played a Chrome Mox and didn't imprint anything, which is legal but stupid, so it might've done that when you loaded the savegame.

[Salbei]

Yeah i have noticed that. First time i loaded it played Juggernaut, 2nd time it played a different card. Kinda weird.

[Salbei]

The savegame is corrupted.


This is a giveaway that something wrong is going on.
Happened to me in the past when i tried to post savegames.

This is very similar to Landfall trigger "bugs" so i will just confirm this without further testing.

Please keep the current savegame in that topic and try to create a saveable situation (both cards in hand and enough mana in play) and post a different savegame.

Confirmed - need a working savegame though.