Page 8 of 11

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 23 Feb 2017, 00:18
by Arcanist
ahkren wrote:PZ1 should be complete at previous link
PZ2 looks good at previous link, needs a higher res expansion symbol at some point, haven't gotten to that yet.
I think I found a couple of issues in PZ1:
  • Card numbers for Kalemne's Captain and Kalemne, Disciple of Iroas look like they have been swapped. The one that should be numbered 107 should be 007 and the other way around. Are you using a script to sort and number cards automatically? If so, this may have happened because the OS and the program you used disagree on the sorting order for commas and apostrophes;
  • Card #105 i.e. Hull Breach is missing its collector info (card number, set, artist);
  • The card number assigned to The Mimeoplasm also seemed suspicious, but looking at the first Commander set, it seems that the card name is considered as starting with "M" instead of "T". I never noticed it before. Funny that...

I have not had a chance to look at PZ2 yet.

Edit: I just had one quick look at PZ2, and set sizes which appear next to card numbers look weird: There are only 10 tokens, yet the Bird Token mentions 21. Standard cards also disagree on the set size: Some mention 351, some 221, some 210, etc. Is this intended?

Edit 2: I just noticed that Hull Breach had already been fixed since I downloaded it. That's one down then...

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 23 Feb 2017, 01:39
by ahkren
MTGO doesn't have proper set numbers for PZ2, they are based on the original set. Which is a touch annoying. I may have to give them proper numbering. There are 61 non-token cards.

I've fixed Kalemne's Captain and Kalemne, Disciple of Iroas. You were correct, they were reversed. I was doing them by hand, so I must have switched them by accident. Will upload soon.

I'll take a closer look at the tokens, I may have missed changing some of the numbering changes. Tokens are completely done by hand.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 23 Feb 2017, 02:07
by Arcanist
ahkren wrote:MTGO doesn't have proper set numbers for PZ2, they are based on the original set. Which is a touch annoying. I may have to give them proper numbering. There are 61 non-token cards.
I was just wondering if set sizes were intentionally different, or if this was a mistake. Since those cards have their own expansion symbol, I think they should get their own number as well. At least that is how I see it.

ahkren wrote:I'll take a closer look at the tokens, I may have missed changing some of the numbering changes. Tokens are completely done by hand.
Yes, I forgot to mention it: The order of PZ1 tokens and emblems seems weird as well: Eldrazi tokens are listed first and emblems in reverse alphabetical order for instance.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 23 Feb 2017, 02:15
by ahkren
I seem to have switched the collector's numbers on Ezuri, Claw of Progress and Ezuri's Predation as well, which is now fixed in the master file.

Colorless non-artifacts have historically been at the beginning of the collectors numbering. Emblems were just a mistake while rushing. I'll correct those.

I should have everything fixed and new versions uploaded tonight.



Edit: Some problems arose, should have it fixed tomorrow.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 23 Feb 2017, 18:30
by ahkren
New versions of PZ1 and PZ2 uploaded to previous link

Edit: TPR with tokens https://mega.nz/#F!AhtFAJgS!CRDP-9JzEnG9Ehoep1jRuQ

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 24 Feb 2017, 01:25
by Arcanist
ahkren wrote:Colorless non-artifacts have historically been at the beginning of the collectors numbering.
Ah yes, they are not artifacts. That explains it.

ahkren wrote:I seem to have switched the collector's numbers on Ezuri, Claw of Progress and Ezuri's Predation as well, which is now fixed in the master file.
You are right. I was really really tired and I completely missed it. Sorry for that. Double-checking now, I missed another mistake: The set size is also incorrect on the PZ2 Spirit Token. That is all I could find for now. Excellent work by the way: These digital sets are awesome.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 24 Feb 2017, 04:11
by ahkren
Argh, I thought I fixed all the tokens, looks like I missed one, thanks. I'll have that fixed and uploaded in a few minutes.

I am glad they are appreciated, they are not an insignificant amount of work, but utterly satisfying once complete.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 24 Feb 2017, 05:37
by Scryfall
ahkren wrote:I am glad they are appreciated, they are not an insignificant amount of work, but utterly satisfying once complete.
Wanted to add that these renders are 100%, totally, absolutely appreciated. You are basically the only source of MTGO set images that aren't blurry screenshots.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 24 Feb 2017, 21:40
by ahkren
I have to say thank you to everyone proofreading these. I know I miss things and sometimes have to rush on this project due to kids or other factors. I really appreciate the assistance.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 25 Feb 2017, 15:57
by Arcanist
ahkren wrote:I have to say thank you to everyone proofreading these. I know I miss things and sometimes have to rush on this project due to kids or other factors. I really appreciate the assistance.
I am just glad I have something to proofread at all. You and the rest of the HQ card project are doing an incredible job. I don't have Photoshop, so I am just trying to help in a different way. It is really too bad that the same type of project does not exist for other card games. At least not at this level of quality.

For now, I am mostly focusing on card names and numbers when proofreading because these are the attributes that are most likely to be wrong. Eventually I would like to double-check the rest, but that is a bit more challenging to automate.

That being said, I am writing because I found a small glitch in the TPR release ;). The card number on the Saproling token should be 6 instead of 5 I believe.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 25 Feb 2017, 16:44
by ahkren
Arcanist wrote:That being said, I am writing because I found a small glitch in the TPR release ;). The card number on the Saproling token should be 6 instead of 5 I believe.
Fixed and uploaded.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 25 Feb 2017, 18:17
by charlequin
ahkren wrote:Fixed and uploaded.
Could you repost the link for the TPR folder?

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 25 Feb 2017, 18:52
by ahkren

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 25 Feb 2017, 19:54
by ahkren
Noticed that the entire TPR render had a 1px white strip at the top because the underlay border was off. Fixed and reuploading.

Re: MTGO Masters Editions

PostPosted: 30 Mar 2017, 01:59
by Scryfall
During the MTGO update for Modern Masters 2017, Wizards added additional cards to PZ2, but instead of appending to the set numbers, they added the new cards and then re-numbered the entire set. :/

Here's a link to the new set data (remove spaces):
Code: Select all
gist . github . com/csuhta/43ce2bb4ac1f3fd6a0842fb47acc4385