Top Ten Wishlist

[BVDM]

Hello,
I'd like to see some more legacy/vintage staples (if they can be coded) like
1 Metalworker
2 Chalice of the Void
3 Karn, Silver Golem
- Null Rod
- Razormane Masticore
- Pithing Needle
4 Aluren
6 Mulch
5 Nantuko Monastery
7 Rishadan Port
- Glacial Chasm
8 Faerie Conclave
- Nomad Stadium
- Cavern Harpy
- Darkblast
- Imperial Seal
9 Ad Nauseam
- Bazaar of Wonders
- Accumulated Knowledge
10 Intuition
- Misdirection
- Repeal
- Stifle
- Runed Halo
- Squee, Goblin Nabob

Just some ideas... I numbered those I really like from 1 to 10, thanks for doing this project!

[EviL_CLonE]

Wonder and Intuition PLEASE! Now that we have Accumulated Knowledge and the like, a decent Tog deck can be builded.

[aww1979]

You guys have done a great job so far! Here are a few that I don't remember anyone asking for yet. Dream Halls and Ethersworn Canonist might be pretty hard to make, but the rest all do things or combinations of things that existing cards already do.

Dream Halls (for old school academy deck; maybe codeable somehow by using Force of Will, Contagion, etc?)
Squandered Resources (for old school prosbloom, should be pretty easy, just sac a land and add one mana)
Stroke of Genius (for academy deck and others, straight hack of Braingeyser in instant form)
Trygon Predator (for weenie decks, just a creature that Disenchants every hit)
Ethersworn Canonist (for weenie decks; not sure how this would be coded)
Chalice of the Void (just plain awesome; probably doable based on Gaddock Teeg)
Future Sight (I love this card, probably doable based on Oracle of Mul Daya)
Phage the Untouchable (This card is fun, might be tough to ensure he kills you if you cheat him into play though)
Temporal Aperture (from Kai Budde's famous Wildfire / Covetous Dragon deck, probably doable based on anything that cheats spells into play like Maelstrom Angel)

[TapToSacrifice]

Hiya!

I don't have top 10 at the moment, more a top 3 list:

Pendrell Mists - Along with card #2 this would allow me to play my 'Grinding Wintermists' deck (Winter Orb + Pendrell Mists + Propaganda + Grindstone + lots of artifact mana)

Grindstone - see above

Gerrard's Wisdom - I use Library of Leng a lot, so...

Cheers!

[Vecc]

Temporal Aperture (from Kai Budde's famous Wildfire / Covetous Dragon deck, probably doable based on anything that cheats spells into play like Maelstrom Angel)

Temporal Aperture, now that would be nice. Wildfire was one of my favorite decks ever, and that card was a nice way to spend all your extra mana.

Hm, I don't have a Top Ten list built yet... but Astral Slide would probably be in there somewhere. I have a thing for that engine.

Also, Glen Elendra Archmage, Venser, Shaper Savant (I guess it should be possible with stuff with Boomerang and Remand in the game), Duplicant, Debtors' Knell, Ghost Council of Orzhova, Teneb, the Harvester, Korlash, Heir to Blackblade, Epochrasite (guess this one is a no-no since suspend isn't in-game yet, but figured I'd at least mention it anyway) and Worldheart Phoenix.

Looks like I had a Top Ten list after all.

[aww1979]

Heh I almost put Debtor's Knell on my list, but I decided not to be too greedy :p

[Arnaut Katalan]

Really "plane" card - Celestine Reef , Horizon Boughs , Tazeem etc.?

[Final Fortune]

Blue, blue, blue...(Standard)

AEther Tradewinds
Bant Charm
Countersquall
Dispel
Essence Scatter
Flashfreeze
Soul Manipulation
Spell Contortion
Spell Snip
Sleep
Telemin Performance
Memory Erosion
Mind Control
Vapor Snare

[Final Fortune]

Black, black, black...(Standard)

Doom Blade
Smother
Bone Splinters
Consume Spirit
Deny Reality
Haunting Echoes
Morbid Bloom
Rise from the Grave

[Enchanteur]

Some cards useful in enchantress decks :

The 5 seals !
Exemple : Seal of fire


And cards with my prefered hability :

Flashback !
Madness !

[Final Fortune]

Standard!!!

Etherwrought Page
Sen Triplets
Sphinx Sovereign
Enigma Sphinx
Gwafa Hazid, Profiteer
Hindering Light
Offering to Asha
Talon Trooper
Unbender Tine
Ethersworn Adjudicator
Filigree Sages
Lich's Mirror
Scourglass
Sharding Sphinx

[Broolex]

Guta, sorry for sending another list, but I'm noticing that Thopter Combo decks are gaining popularity in Legacy lately. Do you think that Thopter Foundry and Sword of the Meek could be coded?

Thats my new wishlist:

1 Spellstutter Sprite
2 Mistbind Clique
3 Thopter Foundry
4 Sword of the Meek
5 Radiant, Archangel
6 Mother of Runes
7 Cavern Harpy


Thanks a lot!

Cheers

[monopoman]

1.) Sterling Grove (GW Solitaire)
2.) Elephant Grass (GW Solitaire)
3.) Orim's Chant (Scepter.dec)
4.) Solitary Confinement (GW Solitaire)
5.) Replenish (GW Solitaire)
6.) Karmic Justice (GW Solitaire)
7.) Martyr of Sands (MWC)
8.) Proclamation of Rebirth (MWC)
8.) Ad Nauseam (Tendrils best friend.)
9.) Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth (Nice interaction with Cabal Coffers)
10.) Ghostly Prison (GW Solitaire)

I figure these cards would add quite a bit to the competitive edge to the game. I appreciate my other suggestions being added before .

[Salbei]

I´m very grateful for the work done thus far and just in case someone got too much time and doesn´t know what to do here is an additional list of cards i´d like to see.

(Mostly casual stuff in no particular order)

playables:
1) Thornling (good + fun)
2) Pithing Needle (good)
3) Engineered Plague (not sure how much play this would see since it is usually a sideboard card)
4) Chainer's Edict (Diabolic Edict + Flashback)
5) Null Rod (fish)
6) Ninja of the Deep Hours (for fish)
7) Uba Mask (Uba Staxx)
8 ) Extirpate
9 ) Cranial Extraction
10 ) Chalice of the Void
11) Auriok Salvagers
12) Trygon Predator
13) Ethersworn Canonist
14) Aven Mindcensor

fun section:
1) The Medalions ( Emerald Medallion , Jet Medallion , Pearl Medallion , Ruby Medallion , Sapphire Medallion )
2) Grinning Deamon (fun)
3) Firespout (pretty good)
4) Nether Traitor (fun/weenie)
5) Anarchist (for Proteus Staff - just the Izzet would be enough though)
6) Gelectrode (just for fun)
7) Izzet Chronarch (for Proteus Staff )
Bottled Cloister (now this is a challenge ^^)
9) Muse Vessel ( Disrupting Scepter 2.0 )
10) Proteus Staff (fun with manlands or Anarchist / Izzet Chronarch)
11) Reclaim (fun on Isochron Scepter, would really like to see that one)
12) Mirri's Guile (actually good)
13) Nostalgic Dreams (nice card)
14) Sowing Salt
15) Eradicate
16) Counterbore
17) Quash
18) Orcish Settlers
19) Dwarven Miner
20) Shard Phoenix
21) Weatherseed Treefolk
22) Anathemancer
23) Kathari Bomber
24) Veteran Explorer
25) Akuta, Born of Ash
26) Augury Adept
27) Coiling Oracle
28) Gigapede
29) Necroplasm
30) Overbeing of Myth
31) Korlash, Heir to Blackblade
32) Mirri the Cursed
33) Mortivore
34) Avatar of Discord
35) Baru, Fist of Krosa
36) Haunting Echoes

lot of Cards with Suspend:
grey them out + suspend counter( like Tawno´s Coffin creatures ) if it is possible

Greater Gargadon
Nihilith
Curse of the Cabal
Festering March
Living End
Arc Blade
Plunder
Rift Bolt (!)
Wheel of Fate
Hypergenesis
Search for Tomorrow
Ancestral Vision (!)
Chronomantic Escape
Restore Balance
Benalish Commander
Durkwood Baloth
Errant Ephemeron
Keldon Halberdier
Knight of Sursi
Nantuko Shaman

---

stuff that could be replaced:
(a lot of these cards are either totally outdated and will never get into a constructed deck,are plain crap or sideboard cards for sealed deck - you are supposed to use the other version for sealed deck anyway so there is no point for them wasting slots in the constructed version. And if people miss some of the cards they can still be used at the custom version)

List A to E (over 60 cards - i´ll list more if needed)

Abbey Gargoyle (junk)
Abomination (junk)
Absorb (junk)
Abu Jafar (junk)
Active Volcano (sideboard card , junk)
Aerathi Berserker (junk)
Alabaster Potion (junk)
Alchors Tomb (junk)
Amulet of Kroog (junk)
Anaba Shaman (junk)
Anaba Spirit Crafter (junk)
Ancient Spring (junk)
Angelic Curator (junk)
Angel´s Feather (junk)
Angus Mackenzie (actually fun)
Animate Wall (junk)
Arcades Sabboth (Momir)
Ardent Militia (junk)
Arena of the Ancients (super deluxe junk)
Armageddon Clock (fun - but extremly dated)
Army of Allah (junk)
Artifact Blast (sideboard ...actually forget it^^)
Ashnod´s Battle Gear (junk)
Asmira, Holy Avenger (junk)
Aven Cloudchaser (junk)
Aven Flock (junk)
Axelrod (Momir)
Backfire (junk)
Balduvian Barbarians (junk)
Bartel Runeaxe (Momir)
Black Mana Battery (there are really enough manafixers)
Blaze of Glory (junk)
Boris Devilboon (just wasting 2 slots with its token)
Carnival of Souls (junk unless somebody posts a semi-decent decklist^^)
Carrion Wall (junk)
Centaur Archer (sealed deck card , junk otherwise)
Cerulean Wyvern (junk)
Chromium (Momir)
Circle of Protection : Blue (junk)
Circle of Protection : Green (junk)
Circle of Protection : White (junk)
Clockwork Avian (dusty junk)
Coalition Victory ( Door into Nothingness is preferable)
Colossus of Sardia (sad but true ^^)
Conversion (sideboard)
Coral Helm (junk deluxe)
Cosmic Horror (Momir Card)
Craw Giant (the AI is just bad when it comes down to rampage)
Curse Artifact (junk)
Cyclopean Mummy (junk)
Damping Field (junk)
Darkpact (ante)
Demonic Attorney (ante)
Detonate (sideboard - even there it would be junk)
Distorting Lens (junk)
Divine Offering (sideboard - junk)
Douse in Gloom (junk)
Dragon Engine (nostalgic junk)
Dragon´s Claw (junk)
Drifter il-Dal (junk)
Durkwood Boars (sealed deck maybe)
Dwarven Weaponsmith (junk)
Eastern Paladin (sideboard junk)
Elite Javelineer (junk)
Emerald Dragonfly (junk)
Execute (sideboard card)
Eye for an Eye (nostalgic junk)

sorry for the long post

[Enchanteur]

Hello salbei, I'm Ok with you for a lot of theses cards (and probably many more others you didn't mention).

Except theses one :

Absorb (junk) -> I play it !!

Detonate (sideboard - even there it would be junk) -> played in "old school" deck, vintage (just destroy a Mox for R, or destroy another artifact with additional damages).

Played many times in SEALED decks :
Anaba Shaman (junk)
Aven Cloudchaser (junk)
Cerulean Wyvern (junk) -> many green deck played by AI in sealed.
Douse in Gloom (junk) -> A must in sealed.
Eastern Paladin (sideboard junk) -> victory in sealed !
Execute (sideboard card) -> very good in sealed

Carnival of Souls -> need a combo deck (never found one with that card )