Ratings

by **GandoTheBard** » 21 Mar 2009, 00:07

Part 1: the Rares.

Comments: these cards were harder to rate than I thought primarily because I had to also consider among the many criteria that they were rare and need to represent what being a rare card means in the context of magic and forge.

Here is the page for the ratings and my comments some of which were cut off by the Excel exporter:

http://outofthebrokensky.com/mtgforge/ratings.html

bah XLS is not an allowed extension here so I cant even make the original file available to you from this site. Instead I will upload it and link it to my ratings page.

by **GandoTheBard** » 26 Mar 2009, 02:03

I updated the rarities files as per requested... here is the contents:
Rares

Code: Select all: Ajani Goldmane Aluren Ancestral Recall Ancient Silverback Ancient Spider Angel of Despair Arcanis the Omnipotent Ashes to Ashes Badlands Ball Lightning Baru, Fist of Krosa Battlegrace Angel Bayou Beacon of Destruction Beacon of Unrest Belbe's Portal Birds of Paradise Bitterblossom Blistering Firecat Blood Crypt Breeding Pool Bribery Brion Stoutarm Broodmate Dragon Caldera Hellion Caller of the Claw Cateran Overlord Cateran Slaver Chandra Nalaar Char Cho-Manno, Revolutionary Cleanse Conspiracy Convalescent Care Cranial Extraction Crucible of Fire Cruel Tutor Damnation Dark Confidant Defense of the Heart Demonic Tutor Do or Die Doran, the Siege Tower El-Hajjaj Eladamri's Call Elspeth, Knight-Errant Elvish Archers Elvish Farmer Elvish Piper Essence Sliver Evacuation Exalted Angel Feudkiller's Verdict Flagstones of Trokair Flamebreak Flowstone Wyvern Garruk Wildspeaker Gilt-Leaf Archdruid Giltspire Avenger Glint-Eye Nephilim Global Ruin Godless Shrine Granite Gargoyle Guiltfeeder Hallowed Fountain Hammerfist Giant Hanna, Ship's Navigator Hellkite Overlord Hidetsugu's Second Rite Hoofprints of the Stag Howling Mine Hunted Dragon Hystrodon Immaculate Magistrate Imperial Hellkite Infernal Kirin Intrepid Hero Isamaru, Hound of Konda Jedit Ojanen of Efrava Jeska, Warrior Adept Joiner Adept Jokulhaups Jugan, the Rising Star Kaysa Keiga, the Tide Star Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker Kinsbaile Borderguard Kinsbaile Cavalier Knight of the Reliquary Knight of the White Orchid Kokusho, the Evening Star Korlash, Heir to Blackblade Land Tax Leaf-Crowned Elder Lightning Angel Liliana Vess Mad Auntie Magus of the Disk Magus of the Library Magus of the Moat Marble Titan March of Souls Marrow-Gnawer Master of Etherium Mawcor Meglonoth Meloku the Clouded Mirror Memnarch Meng Huo, Barbarian King Might of Oaks Mirri, Cat Warrior Mobilization Mox Diamond Muraganda Petroglyphs Mycoloth Nantuko Shade Nath of the Gilt-Leaf Nevinyrral's Disk Night of Souls' Betrayal Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind Noble Hierarch Onulet Order of Whiteclay Oros, the Avenger Overgrown Tomb Pale Bears Pearl Dragon Phyrexian Arena Plateau Predator Dragon Preeminent Captain Primal Clay Primordial Sage Psionic Blast Pulse of the Tangle Pyroclasm Quirion Dryad Radiant, Archangel Raging Kavu Rakka Mar Ramosian Sky Marshal Ranger of Eos Rathi Assassin Regrowth Retribution of the Meek Reya Dawnbringer Rhys the Redeemed River Merfolk Roc of Kher Ridges Rockshard Elemental Rootwater Thief Rorix Bladewing Royal Assassin Ryusei, the Falling Star Sacred Foundry Savannah Savannah Lions Scrubland Sengir Vampire Sensation Gorger Serendib Efreet Serra Angel Serra Avenger Serra Sphinx Shadowmage Infiltrator Shared Triumph Shivan Dragon Simic Sky Swallower Skullmulcher Sleeper Agent Sol'kanar the Swamp King Solemn Simulacrum Sorceress Queen Spawnwrithe Squee, Goblin Nabob Steam Vents Stomping Ground Sunweb Taiga Talas Warrior Tarox Bladewing Temple Garden Thelonite Hermit Thunder Spirit Titanic Ultimatum Tithe Tolsimir Wolfblood Treva, the Renewer Tropical Island Tundra Underground Sea Vampiric Tutor Vedalken Archmage Vindicate Visara the Dreadful Volcanic Dragon Wall of Kelp Warrior Angel Wheel of Fortune Will-o'-the-Wisp Wort, Boggart Auntie Wrath of God Yore-Tiller Nephilim

Uncommons

Code: Select all: Air Elemental Allied Strategies Anaconda Angel of Light Angel of Mercy Anger Animate Land Arachnoid Arcane Sanctum Armored Griffin Arrogant Vampire Balshan Collaborator Bant Battlemage Battlefield Percher Blade Sliver Bog Wraith Bonded Fetch Boros Swiftblade Branchsnap Lorian Brawn Briarhorn Bull Cerodon Bull Hippo Carrion Ants Cateran Enforcer Cateran Kidnappers Centaur Glade Char-Rumbler Charcoal Diamond Charging Troll Cinder Storm Cloud Djinn Cloudseeder Coastal Tower Concentrate Crazed Skirge Crib Swap Crude Rampart Crumbling Necropolis Daggerclaw Imp Darksteel Gargoyle Desert Drake Dryad Arbor Ebony Treefolk Elfhame Palace Enlightened Tutor Eron the Relentless Eternal Witness Faerie Conclave Fire Diamond Fire Drake Fire Imp Flametongue Kavu Fleetfoot Panther Forbidding Watchtower Furnace Whelp Fury Sliver Gerrard's Verdict Ghor-Clan Bloodscale Ghost Ship Giant Octopus Gloomwidow Gluttonous Slime Gluttonous Zombie Goblin Berserker Goblin Ringleader Goldmeadow Lookout Goliath Spider Guardian of Cloverdell Harmonize Heartwood Treefolk Horned Cheetah Horned Sliver Imperiosaur Imperious Perfect Inspirit Iron Tusk Elephant Iron-Barb Hellion Ivy Dancer Jhessian Infiltrator Jungle Barrier Jungle Shrine Jungle Troll Keening Banshee King Cheetah Kithkin Harbinger Kithkin Rabble Kjeldoran Gargoyle Knight of Meadowgrain Leonin Skyhunter Lightning Helix Llanowar Behemoth Llanowar Mentor Longbow Archer Loxodon Stalwart Lynx Marble Diamond Meadowboon Might Sliver Minions' Murmurs Mistral Charger Mogg Fanatic Moss Diamond Moss Monster Mountain Bandit Mycologist Needle Storm Nettletooth Djinn Nightshade Schemers Orcish Artillery Ornithopter Overrun Pardic Collaborator Patagia Golem Patrol Signaler Penumbra Kavu Peregrine Drake Phantom Monster Phantom Warrior Phyrexian Gargantua Pongify Primal Boost Primeval Shambler Primoc Escapee Psychotrope Thallid Puppeteer Pyre Charger Pyrohemia Ramosian Captain Ramosian Commander Ramosian Revivalist Ranger en-Vec Rathi Fiend Razorfoot Griffin Rhox Charger Rhox War Monk Ridgeline Rager Ridgetop Raptor Riptide Crab River Bear River Boa Sabertooth Wyvern Sabretooth Tiger Salt Marsh Saltblast Sandbar Serpent Sarcomite Myr Savage Lands Screeching Harpy Sea Eagle Sea Spirit Seaside Citadel Segovian Leviathan Sengir Autocrat Sentinels of Glen Elendra Shimmering Barrier Shivan Oasis Shriekmaw Sigiled Paladin Silver Erne Sky Diamond Sky Spirit Skyhunter Skirmisher Soul Feast Soul Warden Sparkspitter Spitting Drake Spitting Spider Sporesower Thallid Springjack Shepherd Sprouting Thrinax Standstill Starlit Angel Steam Spitter Steel Wall Stonecloaker Stratozeppelid Stronghold Zeppelin Sunhome, Fortress of the Legion Sylvan Messenger Tangle Spider Tempest Drake Thieving Magpie Threaten Thunder-Thrash Elder Thundering Giant Tower Gargoyle Towering Baloth Treefolk Harbinger Uktabi Orangutan Unseen Walker Unyaro Bee Sting Urborg Volcano Uthden Troll Valor Vedalken Mastermind Viridian Shaman Vitu-Ghazi, the City-Tree Wall of Air Wall of Blossoms Wall of Mulch Wall of Swords Warthog Watchwolf Whip Sergeant Wild Ox Wind Dancer Wirewood Hivemaster Wojek Embermage Wolf-Skull Shaman Wonder Worldly Tutor Yavimaya Enchantress Zebra Unicorn Zombify

Commons

Code: Select all: Advance Scout Akki Drillmaster Akrasan Squire Alaborn Musketeer Ambassador Oak Amrou Scout Amrou Seekers Anaba Shaman Anarchist Angelic Blessing Angelic Wall Anodet Lurker Anurid Murkdiver Argothian Swine Ascending Aven Ashen-Skin Zubera Assault Zeppelid Aven Fisher Aven Riftwatcher Aven Squire Avian Changeling Barkhide Mauler Battering Craghorn Battering Sliver Bay Falcon Bayou Dragonfly Belbe's Percher Benalish Knight Blightspeaker Blockade Runner Bog Imp Bog Raiders Bonesplitter Sliver Boomerang Brainstorm Breath of Life Brute Force Cackling Flames Cackling Imp Canopy Spider Canyon Wildcat Capashen Knight Castle Raptors Cateran Brute Cateran Persuader Cavern Thoctar Charging Slateback Chartooth Cougar Cloud Elemental Cloudcrown Oak Cloudheath Drake Coercion Commune with Nature Corrupt Counsel of the Soratami Court Archers Covert Operative Dark Banishing Darkling Stalker Darklit Gargoyle Darksteel Ingot Daru Lancer Deeptread Merrow Defiant Falcon Dirtwater Wraith Disciple of Kangee Disenchant Diving Griffin Douse in Gloom Dream Stalker Dripping-Tongue Zubera Dross Prowler Drowned Drudge Reavers Drudge Skeletons Druid of the Anima Dungeon Shade Duress Dusk Imp Echoing Decay Echoing Truth Ekundu Griffin Elite Cat Warrior Elvish Fury Elvish Herder Ember-Fist Zubera Erratic Explosion Esper Cormorants Essence Warden Expunge Faceless Butcher Feral Shadow Fetid Horror Fire Ambush Fire Elemental Fog of Gnats Foxfire Oak Fresh Volunteers Frostling Frostweb Spider Funeral Charm Furnace Spirit Fyndhorn Elves Gaea's Skyfolk Gemhide Sliver Gerrard's Command Ghost Warden Ghostfire Giant Growth Giant Spider Giant Warthog Gnarled Mass Goblin Cavaliers Goblin Chariot Goblin Deathraiders Goblin Hero Goblin Mountaineer Goblin Raider Goblin Skycutter Goblin Spelunkers Goblin Striker Goretusk Firebeast Gorilla Chieftain Gravedigger Guardians of Akrasa Guided Strike Havenwood Wurm Heart Sliver Highway Robber Hillcomber Giant Hoar Shade Hooded Kavu Horned Kavu Horned Troll Hornet Cobra Horseshoe Crab Hundroog Hurloon Minotaur Hyalopterous Lemure Hymn to Tourach Icatian Scout Ichor Slick Impulse Inner-Flame Acolyte Jukai Messenger Jungle Weaver Kabuto Moth Kavu Climber Kavu Glider Keen-Eyed Archers Keeneye Aven Keepers of the Faith Kird Ape Knight Errant Kodama's Reach Kranioceros Kyren Glider Lab Rats Land Leeches Leaf Dancer Leaf Gilder Lightning Blast Lightning Bolt Lightning Elemental Lightning Hounds Lignify Lionheart Maverick Living Airship Llanowar Dead Llanowar Elves Loch Korrigan Looming Shade Lost Soul Lowland Giant Lucent Liminid Macetail Hystrodon Maggot Carrier Man-o'-War Marsh Boa Merfolk of the Pearl Trident Merrow Levitator Mesa Falcon Metathran Soldier Metathran Zombie Mire Boa Misshapen Fiend Moaning Spirit Moor Fiend Morsel Theft Mountain Goat Mudbutton Torchrunner Mulldrifter Muscle Sliver Nameless Inversion Naturalize Needlepeak Spider Nezumi Cutthroat Nightguard Patrol Nightshade Stinger Norwood Archers Obelisk of Bant Obelisk of Esper Obelisk of Grixis Obelisk of Jund Obelisk of Naya Oblivion Ring Obsidian Giant Ogre Berserker Opt Orochi Sustainer Oubliette Outrider of Jhess Pallid Mycoderm Parapet Watchers Pegasus Charger Pendrell Drake Penumbra Bobcat Penumbra Spider Pestilence Phyrexian Battleflies Phyrexian Monitor Phyrexian Rager Phyrexian Walker Plague Beetle Plated Rootwalla Plated Sliver Plated Spider Plover Knights Prickly Boggart Primal Plasma Prodigal Pyromancer Prodigal Sorcerer Pygmy Pyrosaur Pygmy Razorback Python Raging Cougar Raging Minotaur Raiding Nightstalker Raise the Alarm Ramosian Lieutenant Ramosian Sergeant Rathi Intimidator Ravenous Rats Razorfin Hunter Razortooth Rats Redwood Treefolk Reflex Sliver Regress Repulse Restless Bones Rhox Bodyguard Rib Cage Spider Ridge Rannet Righteous Avengers Rip-Clan Crasher Rishadan Airship Rock Badger Roofstalker Wight Rootwalla Rootwater Commando Rune-Cervin Rider Rushwood Dryad Sakura-Tribe Elder Sandbar Merfolk Sandstone Warrior Scarwood Treefolk Scathe Zombies Scorching Spear Scryb Sprites Serpent Warrior Serra Zealot Shanodin Dryads Shatter Shield Sphere Shock Shore Snapper Silent-Chant Zubera Silver Myr Sinew Sliver Skirk Shaman Skyhunter Patrol Skyhunter Prowler Skyknight Legionnaire Skyshroud Falcon Skyshroud Troll Skyshroud Troopers Slaughterhouse Bouncer Sleight of Hand Snapping Drake Sokenzan Bruiser Sootfeather Flock Southern Elephant Spark Spray Sparksmith Spined Wurm Spitting Gourna Spotted Griffin Squirming Mass Steel Leaf Paladin Steward of Valeron Stone Kavu Stone-Throwing Devils Stonewood Invoker Strangling Soot Streetbreaker Wurm Sunlance Synchronous Sliver Talas Air Ship Talas Scout Talruum Minotaur Tarfire Tattered Drake Tel-Jilad Exile Tendrils of Corruption Terror Thallid Thallid Shell-Dweller Thorn-Thrash Viashino Thought Courier Timberwatch Elf Titanic Bulvox Torii Watchward Tower Drake Trained Armodon Transluminant Treespring Lorian Tribal Flames Tyrranax Urborg Elf Urborg Syphon-Mage Valiant Guard Venerable Monk Venser's Sliver Veteran Armorer Viashino Fangtail Viashino Grappler Viashino Slasher Vine Trellis Viscid Lemures Vodalian Merchant Volcanic Hammer Volcano Imp Vulshok Berserker Vulshok Sorcerer War Mammoth Watcher Sliver Waveskimmer Aven Wayward Soul Weatherseed Elf Whip-Spine Drake Whispering Shade Wild Aesthir Wild Colos Wild Elephant Wild Griffin Wild Jhovall Wild Mongrel Wildsize Willow Dryad Willow Faerie Wind Drake Windseeker Centaur Windwright Mage Winged Sliver Wings of Velis Vel Winnower Patrol Wirewood Elf Words of Wisdom Yavimaya Ancients Yavimaya Wurm Yoked Plowbeast Youthful Knight Zephyr Falcon

These rarities are set for both draft and quest mode which is why I put the rare lands back in. The selection is MUCH wider than my last "set" because there are alot of cards that are new that need to be tested and people of course want to play with them.

For the most part I took out the overcosted/and or generic cards that have in the past been filler. I personally think MTGForge does not need such cards as they only exist primarily to create a wider dichotomy between good and bad cards. I think the skills used in limited can be subtler than that. I hope you enjoy these files. Please let me know if there are any glaring mistakes. There are a few uncommons I have rated as Rares because of their power or actual rarity.

by **GandoTheBard** » 26 Mar 2009, 02:04

PS as my attachment quota has been reached you will have to make your own files from the lists...:/

by **DennisBergkamp** » 30 Mar 2009, 01:04

Gando,

Thanks!!!!
For some reason I missed this post, next release I will include these as the rarity files.

By the way, these ratings could be very useful for generating a list of cards and attaching a $ amount to them once we decide to add a shop in quest mode.

by **GandoTheBard** » 30 Mar 2009, 02:09

Heh well I was sort of waylaid by a coding project for another game so I haven't finished the uncommons ratings yet. I know Im a slacker. lol. I hope to get both uncommons and commons done by next week maybe.

by **GandoTheBard** » 09 Apr 2009, 00:06

Well Ive managed to do half the uncommons. Not counting whatever has been added since midmarch. I cant keep up with the additional cards it seems :/ Anyway...the reason it takes so long is I give a comment for many of the cards...I probably should just rate them and shut up. lol.

by **mtgrares** » 09 Apr 2009, 19:27

GandoTheBard - Heh well I was sort of waylaid by a coding project for another game.

Cool, what game and what computer language?

by **GandoTheBard** » 09 Apr 2009, 21:24

http://tkdragon.com/tkd

is the game "Teh Kinkeh Dragon" --- a much ammended Text Based game based on the original dragon knight source code which was based on the old japanese famicon titles Dragon Warrior. The game as it is now stands almost no resemblence to that game at all however

I made the most current help documentation for it (http://outofthebrokensky.com/tkd/eh.html) but we have not hooked it into the game because its going through major changes for the next version, and I dont mind hosting it for now, since our player base is small.

My app was a simple js calculator for skills and items in various towns. (http://outofthebrokensky.com/tkd/skilltable.html) nothing fancy...but it took a long time to input the data.

Ratings

Ratings

Re: Ratings

Re: Ratings

Re: Ratings

Re: Ratings

Re: Ratings

Re: Ratings

Re: Ratings

Who is online

Main Menu

User Menu

Our Partners

Who is online

Who is online

Main Menu

User Menu

Our Partners

Who is online

Login Form