Page 10 of 10

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 15 Apr 2017, 20:30
by DaniUG
Also found another weird behaviour.
I believe the AI should not play Mwonvuli Ooze in the first turn if only has one land (no moxes and such)
A couple of times AI has done that and the cumulative upkeep kills the Ooze at the beginning of the second turn.
So, not a great play...

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 17 Apr 2017, 18:46
by SIXTY
Hi, guys! What about new version? Or where i may download a snapshotbuild?

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 18 Apr 2017, 00:28
by friarsol
SIXTY wrote:Hi, guys! What about new version? Or where i may download a snapshotbuild?
New release is planned for the prerelease on Friday.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 18 Apr 2017, 13:40
by Seravy
In quest mode, I won one then got draw in the other (earthquake killed both players).
I got the usual "next game" button with the result shown as 1-0 but pressing it put me back to the main menu as though the match was over. (bazaar is off so it's best of 3)
No idea if it was counted as a win or not in the end but I'm pretty sure there should have been another game in this match.
Bug?

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 18 Apr 2017, 15:06
by friarsol
Seravy wrote:In quest mode, I won one then got draw in the other (earthquake killed both players).
I got the usual "next game" button with the result shown as 1-0 but pressing it put me back to the main menu as though the match was over. (bazaar is off so it's best of 3)
No idea if it was counted as a win or not in the end but I'm pretty sure there should have been another game in this match.
Bug?
Yea there's an issue with Draws and Forge, which is why the two cards that can Draw the game haven't been implemented. It shouldn't be too hard to fix, maybe after the new edition is ironed out I'll take a look

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 18 Apr 2017, 17:25
by drislands
Hi, I found an odd interaction involving Contagion Engine and I think Neurok Commando. I had 3 creatures on the field, including a Neurok Commando and Kemba, Kha Regent, and my opponent playing the Ramsey deck played Contagion Engine. It didn't place an -1/-1 counters on my creatures though, with the log saying it failed to target. I'd include a screenshot, but unfortunately the "Report a Bug" dialog froze the whole application when I clicked the "Report" button. I am now doing some tests to see if I can narrow down the issue:

Test 1: Opponent has 6 Swamp in play, 1 Contagion Engine in hand. I have 1 Neurok Commando in play. AI casts Contagion Engine, card functions as it should.

Test 2: Same setup as Test 1, except I also have Kemba, Kha Regent in play. AI casts Contagion Engine, log reports "[Couldn't add to stack, failed to target]".

Test 3: Same setup as Test 1, except I have Kemba, Kha Regent in play and NOT the Neurok Commando. AI casts Contagion Engine, log reports same error as Test 2.

So I guess it seems there's some weird issue with Kemba, Kha Regent then, and not the Neurok Command as I originally thought. I'm attaching a screenshot from Test 3 here.

ETA: In the midst of another game, and the same issue came up, per my second attachment. I didn't have Kemba, Kha Regent in play this time, but I did have Elspeth Tirel. Both last time and this time I was in a Quest with Fantasy mode set; perhaps this is related..?

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 19 Apr 2017, 15:37
by Seravy
When Pulse of Llanowar is in play, every time I tap a land for mana, the game asks me for a color TWICE when it should do once (I have only one copy of the enchantment and my lands produce 1 mana when tapped).
Furthermore, it disables the "auto" button for paying costs which is extremely inconvenient - to play a 6 mana spell you have to select mana colors 12 times manually.


...erm no it's worse than that.
I just got prompted for a color during the AI's turn without trying to do anything and even if I do pick a color the window just comes back and asks again. I can't continue playing and have to concede the match...except I can't even do that, since the window is blocking the interface.

I guess for the time being I'll remove this card from the set as it pretty much crashes the game.

This card is buggy and I might as well forfeit this tournament - without this card I can't play two of my 3 dragon legends.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 20 Apr 2017, 00:06
by Seravy
Next bug :
AI casts Assault/Battery which I counter using Prohibit with kicker. Battery has a CMC of 4 and should get countered but did not.
Split cards on the stack count as only the half being played, so the CMC is 4, not 5, unless this rule was changed?

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 20 Apr 2017, 00:19
by drislands
Seravy wrote:Next bug :
AI casts Assault/Battery which I counter using Prohibit with kicker. Battery has a CMC of 4 and should get countered but did not.
Split cards on the stack count as only the half being played, so the CMC is 4, not 5, unless this rule was changed?
This was changed actually, with the release of Amonkhet. I don't know if the rules are meant to apply until the release or not, but it is official. I'd link the article here, but as a new user I can't link to external URLs. You can find the article in question by searching for "split card rules update Amonkhet"; it should be the first result.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 20 Apr 2017, 01:04
by friarsol
drislands wrote:
Seravy wrote:Next bug :
AI casts Assault/Battery which I counter using Prohibit with kicker. Battery has a CMC of 4 and should get countered but did not.
Split cards on the stack count as only the half being played, so the CMC is 4, not 5, unless this rule was changed?
This was changed actually, with the release of Amonkhet. I don't know if the rules are meant to apply until the release or not, but it is official. I'd link the article here, but as a new user I can't link to external URLs. You can find the article in question by searching for "split card rules update Amonkhet"; it should be the first result.
Amonkhet only changed when split cards weren't on the stack. If it's on the stack it's exactly the same as it has been.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 20 Apr 2017, 01:13
by drislands
friarsol wrote:
drislands wrote:
Seravy wrote:Next bug :
AI casts Assault/Battery which I counter using Prohibit with kicker. Battery has a CMC of 4 and should get countered but did not.
Split cards on the stack count as only the half being played, so the CMC is 4, not 5, unless this rule was changed?
This was changed actually, with the release of Amonkhet. I don't know if the rules are meant to apply until the release or not, but it is official. I'd link the article here, but as a new user I can't link to external URLs. You can find the article in question by searching for "split card rules update Amonkhet"; it should be the first result.
Amonkhet only changed when split cards weren't on the stack. If it's on the stack it's exactly the same as it has been.
Of course, my mistake. I was a bit too quick to think I had the answer and didn't fully read the post. Thanks for the clarification.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 20 Apr 2017, 15:45
by CokedUpZombie
Forgotten Ancient currently only allows you to select one creature but should allow you to choose any number of creatures.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 20 Apr 2017, 18:51
by friarsol
CokedUpZombie wrote:Forgotten Ancient currently only allows you to select one creature but should allow you to choose any number of creatures.
If that's a select box, it might be a multi-select box.

Re: Forge Beta Release: 02-20-2017 ver. 1.5.60

PostPosted: 22 Apr 2017, 09:31
by Seravy
When Custodi Squire comes into play, it doesn't seem to notice all the cards the ability could target.
For example I have Conjurer's Bauble in my graveyard and no other cards - there was no voting and I couldn't return any card to my hand.

...also, unless I had extremely bad luck, I think starter/tournament decks in quest mode can no longer have foil cards in them which wasn't the case a few versions ago.