Achivement discussion

[Marek14]

Well, I am abroad at this time, so I am limited in looking things up. If you can tell me the achievements, I will come up with something, otherwise I will do it in July.

[Agetian]

Marek, please let me know if you're back to make the possible LTR achievements We are implementing the Ring mechanic upstream, so now might be a good time to complete the remaining set elements as well. Thanks a lot in advance!

- Agetian

[Marek14]

Yup, I'm back, no problem. Keeping to alt-wins and planeswalkers, I have:

Frodo, Sauron's Bane
Middle-Earth Saved
Sorry, Sauron! Your ring is in another volcano!

And that's it in LTR/LTC, so I wonder if there are other achievements you'd like.

As for CMM, that at least has planeswalkers. But out of the 4 new ones, only one has a true ultimate:

Vronos, Masked Inquisitor
Vronos's Best Friend
"Let's see Garruk resist NOW!"

[Agetian]

Thanks a lot for covering these! I think this is it so far, at least the stuff I can also think of...

- Agetian

[Agetian]

Dear members,
Please feel free to provide ideas for the WOE/WOC sets when it comes to achievements Thanks in advance!

- Agetian

[Marek14]

Ashiok, Wicked Manipulator
Ashiok's Oblivion
"I have seen nothingness before. Let me guide you."

And that... seems to be it. No other planeswalkers, no alt-win conditions.

Though I'd suggest an achievement for playing Once Upon a Time and The End in the same game

[Rmrp]

I have a question regarding the Overkill and Commander damage achievements.
Are there any specifics on how exactly they do unlock or are they just bugged?
With Commander dmg I'm stuck at 46 dmg and the Overkill achievement won't go below -193 life.

I did lots of games/matches and constellations, where f.e. all three opponents dropped below -500k life simultaneaously.
With Commander dmg I ONLY attack with the commander and it still won't proc the unlock, even if I kill all 3 by commander dmg.
Do I have to use random generated decks for opponents for these specific achievements? I'm playing against custom decklists for goldfishing, but this doesn't seem to cause problems with other achievements.
Life to Spare did unlock with 18k life.

As you can see in the pic, I'm also far below the 32bit treshold of 4 billion, in fact I tested how the application would react to these numbers too and ofc my Commander went straight to the GY, so that's not it.

[Agetian]

Dear members,
Please feel free to provide ideas for the WHO, LCI, and LCC sets when it comes to achievements Thanks in advance!

- Agetian

[Marek14]

Gallifrey Stands
The Big Thirteen
"I think some of them are probably changelings..."

...and, if you satisfy it the "real" way, with First to Thirteenth Doctor:

The Thirteen Doctors
The greatest reunion the Universe has ever seen!

Quintorius Kand Ultimate:
Quintorius's Archeological Dig
"The past is still alive."

Winning the game after triggering the 1000-counter ability of The Millennium Calendar:
The End of an Era
"If time is cyclical, how could it run out?"

Plus, I feel like there should be a hidden achievement for triggering that ability with exactly 2012 time counters.

[Agetian]

Dear members,
Please feel free to provide ideas for the MKM, MKC, PIP (if applicable) sets when it comes to achievements Thanks in advance!

- Agetian

[Marek14]

Kaya, Spirits' Justice -- no real ultimate

So the only achievement I see would be alternate win through Luck Bobblehead:

Jackpot
Sometimes... the house loses.

[Agetian]

Dear members,
Please feel free to provide ideas for the OTJ, OTC (if applicable) sets when it comes to achievements Thanks in advance!

- Agetian

[Marek14]

Jace Reawakened
Jace's Double Trouble
"If it's worth doing, it's worth doing twice."

Oko, the Ringleader
Oko's Fearsome Posse
"Meet new mooks, same as the old mooks."

[WrightPhilomena]

I don't see a problem with having a few that aren't that hard to achieve. Sure you may not be particularly "achieving" anything, but it does inform the players that there are things to be hunted by doing this type of thing.