Page 7 of 7

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 31 Aug 2010, 15:10
by aww1979
I mentioned it before, but in case it gets lost:
For arabian nights bonus card, I request Future Sight if possible, and Dwarven Miner otherwise. Based on the uncodeable cards wiki, future sight might have some problems, so I'll leave it to jatill's discretion which one to do.

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 01 Sep 2010, 00:37
by monopoman
Okay here is the list of 10 cards that I would like I looked over the list of cards that can not be coded and I don't believe these fall under those categories.

If 1-9 can not be coded please let me know since they are kind of a lump group for one deck. 10 is a card I would like but it doesn't reference the other 9.

1.) Replenish
2.) Sacred Mesa
3.) Elephant Grass
4.) Utopia Sprawl
5.) Sterling Grove
6.) Solitary Confinement
7.) Ground Seal
8.) Words of War
9.) Seal of Primordium
10.) Astral Slide

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 01 Sep 2010, 12:04
by jatill
monopoman wrote:Okay here is the list of 10 cards that I would like I looked over the list of cards that can not be coded and I don't believe these fall under those categories.

If 1-9 can not be coded please let me know since they are kind of a lump group for one deck. 10 is a card I would like but it doesn't reference the other 9.

1.) Replenish
2.) Sacred Mesa
3.) Elephant Grass
4.) Utopia Sprawl
5.) Sterling Grove
6.) Solitary Confinement
7.) Ground Seal
8.) Words of War
9.) Seal of Primordium
10.) Astral Slide
#5 and #6 I can only approximate since players and enchantments can't be given shroud. I can only do the pseudo-shroud that I do for Gaea's Revenge, where is a spell targets it, nothing happens (or in the case of Solitary Confinement, it targets the opponent instead). Ground Seal I can't do at all. That's played in a deck? I would have guessed sideboards at best. And before you ask, Opalescense is totally impossible too :)

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 01 Sep 2010, 20:31
by monopoman
Yeah its mostly good in enchantress cause it basically cycles and puts an enchantment in the field they play a few in the MD.

But yeah Ground Seal is at first glance a SB card.

Well as long as its approximated shroud that sounds good.

I will take Devastating Dreams in place of Ground Seal then.

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 01 Sep 2010, 22:17
by juzamjedi
Yeah - I play Legacy Dredge and Ground Seal SUCKS to play against! heh

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 03 Sep 2010, 20:40
by Cognis
Will there be a tournament this month?

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 03 Sep 2010, 22:30
by jatill
Cognis wrote:Will there be a tournament this month?
I'm not running one this month. Someone else can (and offer 5 prize cards coded by me, total) if they want to do all the work.

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 06 Sep 2010, 17:21
by aww1979
I'm not doing one either because I might be gone the last week of September.

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 06 Sep 2010, 23:28
by Cognis
I could do a tournament this month. I have an idea for a legacy tournament, minimum two colours per deck, maximum 8 non-creature cards (sorcery, instant and so on), minimum 16 multi-coloured cards.

Legacy because I think it's the best format for the tournament.
Minimum two colours per deck because I think it will make it more interesting.
Maximum 8 non-creature cards because I want a really competitive tournament with decks the AI will be able to play well.
Minimum 12 multi-coloured cards per deck because you'll have to rely on good combinations instead of just splashing a colour. If there are to few gold cards to make versatile deck in many combinations I'll reduce the number of mandatory gold cards.

If this is a format you'd like to play say so and I'll run it. Everyone can make an A and a B deck so I'll fill in the holes in the roster with them, of course if there are fewer than 5 players than we'll just skip this month's tournament. You have until saturday to send me the decks so we can start next week.

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 07 Sep 2010, 07:53
by Brandon822
I'm in. Last deck I built is just between your limitations. Just one question: What about planewalkers, I have 8 non-creature spells + two cards of same planewalker(so basically 10 non-creature cards). So is this legal in your opinion?

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 07 Sep 2010, 08:08
by Cognis
Planeswalkers are counted as enchantments so they fit in as non-creature spells.

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 07 Sep 2010, 12:12
by jatill
Cognis-
Want to create a separate thread for this? Does hybrid count as multicolored?

Re: August Tourny (monopman wins with M11 deck)

PostPosted: 07 Sep 2010, 12:17
by Cognis
I will, and hybrid cards count as gold cards as long as they have the colours you play in a deck (sort of an EDH restriction). So Kitchen Finks would go in a WG deck but not in a WB or GU and so on.