Collectible Card Game Headquarters

If you have encountered any problems while using MAGE 1.2.0, you can post them here.
Please mention who you were playing against: Human or the AI type.
Please describe how you got to that point. A screenshot of the battlefield at the moment something went wrong will be useful too. Otherwise, naming the cards that interacted will suffice.
If you get an error log please add that too.

Thank you for your help in detecting bugs.



FIXES DONE FOR THE NEXT VERSION SINCE RELEASE OF 1.2.0
Game/Abilities
* Bestow - Fixed that creature with bestow went to graveyard if enchanted target got protection from a color of the bestow permanent (fixed already on public server).
* Commander - Fixed a bug that if a player lost due to 21 commander damage the message was repeated every time state base effect were checked during the rest of the game of the remaining players (fixed already on public server).

Cards
* Curse of Shallow Graves - Fixed that tokens did not enter the battlefield tapped.
* Curse of Shallow Graves - Changed outcome for better AI behaviour.
* Dungeon Geists - Fixed that the not untap effect lasted forever if the creature with the ability was destroyed or exiled while the ability was on the stack.
* Full Moon's Rise - Fixed that Werewolf creatures you control didn't have trample.
* Helm of Obedience - Added missing sacrifice source and put into play creature effect.
* Joraga Treespeaker - Fixed a bug, that elves did not get the mana ability from Level 5 of the Joraga Treespeaker (caused by wrong handling of continuous effects that added abilities that added abilities).
* Karn Liberated - Fixed that targets of first and second ability were not mandatory.
* Oloro, Ageless Ascetic - Fixed a bug that second ability did not trigger properly.
* Polukranos, World Eater - Fixed a bug, that the damage made by the targeted creatures did not set the source correctly. So e.g. deathtouch was not applied to Polukranos.
* Shipbreaker Kraken - Fixed that the not untap effect lasted forever if the creature with the ability was destroyed or exiled while the ability was on the stack.
* Spinal Embrace - Fixed wrong casting costs.
* Thopter Assembly - Fixed the not working triggered ability.
* Tidebinder Mage - Fixed that the not untap effect lasted forever if the creature with the ability was destroyed or exiled while the ability was on the stack.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I was playing a game against the AI opponent ("mad"). The AI blocked my Pilgrim's Eye (flying) with his Necropede equipped with Avacyn's Collar. There were no cards on the battlefield that granted flying to Necropede, so I believe it was an illegal block. Here's a screenshot in case I'm missing something:



The second weird thing happened immediately after the previous one - the AI chose to apply the triggered ability of Necropede when it died and put a -1/-1 counter on its own (!) Wall of Spears instead of, for example, on my Colossus of Sardia or my other creature.

- Agetian

Agetian wrote:I was playing a game against the AI opponent ("mad"). The AI blocked my Pilgrim's Eye (flying) with his Necropede equipped with Avacyn's Collar. There were no cards on the battlefield that granted flying to Necropede, so I believe it was an illegal block. Here's a screenshot in case I'm missing something:

battlefield-glitch-mage.jpg

That's a bug that happens sometimes and it's not reproducable at will. There is some special logging added if this happens. So please check your server log file ( .../Mage.Server/mageserver.log). There should be a message with the following text: "Found non-flying non-reach creature blocking creature with flying".

After this message there should be added some trace information blocks starting with messages like "Tracing game state...", "Attacker abilities: ", "Blocker abilities: ", "Flying ability id: ", "Reach ability id: ", "Restriction effects:".
Please check if you can find this information in your log file and post it here (as txt attachment). I hope this information can help me to find the cause of this bug.
Thanks in advance.

Agetian wrote:The second weird thing happened immediately after the previous one - the AI chose to apply the triggered ability of Necropede when it died and put a -1/-1 counter on its own (!) Wall of Spears instead of, for example, on my Colossus of Sardia or my other creature. - Agetian

The AI isn't so smart. But for this case I hope I have improved the AI behaviour now.

@ LevelX: Thanks for looking into it! Here's the relevant portion of the log file. Please let me know if this is everything you may need or if I should paste more text.

Code: Select all

WARN  [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:006]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: Found non-flying non-reach creature blocking creature with flying
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:006]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Tracing game state...
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:006]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Necropede could block Pilgrim's Eye
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:006]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:006]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Attacker abilities:
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:006]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      Cast Pilgrim's Eye, id=cf823669-712a-4d7d-95e2-7ec5133f5442
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      Flying, id=97d53877-08d4-49d8-a69c-a7361e16423d
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      When {this} enters the battlefield, you may search your library for a basic land card, reveal it,  and put that card into your hand. Then shuffle your library., id=a1a7d8ec-5164-4738-b575-93c1678df8ef
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Blocker abilities:
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      Cast Necropede, id=4a9acfc0-7030-414e-bb66-d0934fca1687
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      Infect <i>(This creature deals damage to creatures in the form of -1/-1 counters and to players in the form of poison counters.)</i>, id=f89e826d-7a17-4163-a098-f660f9f81f05
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      When {this} dies, you may have put a -1/-1 counter on target creature., id=bf103271-1689-41b3-a7ec-afa9d753eb35
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:007]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]      Vigilance, id=f47266e1-60e0-4d60-a066-92cde9c71e0e
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Flying ability id: 97d53877-08d4-49d8-a69c-a7361e16423d
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Reach ability id: fe79806b-9bdc-40de-ad2d-905b57cde45d
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb] Restriction effects:
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]     mage.abilities.effects.common.combat.CantBeBlockedByCreaturesSourceEffect@6fe28841
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:008]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         id=d9ebaf89-66b5-472d-a1b6-84db443e4299
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         applies to attacker=true
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         applies to blocker=false
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         instanceof: true, ability={this} can't be blocked by Walls.
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         usable: false, ability={this} can't be blocked by Walls.
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         zone: BATTLEFIELD
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         object: mage.sets.elspethvstezzeret.Juggernaut@575294b3
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         contains:true
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:009]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         test_zone: LIBRARY
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         instanceof: true, ability={this} can't be blocked by Walls.
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         usable: false, ability={this} can't be blocked by Walls.
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         zone: BATTLEFIELD
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         object: mage.sets.elspethvstezzeret.Juggernaut@575294b3
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         contains:true
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]         test_zone: LIBRARY
ERROR [2014-01-02 11:14 [17:010]] TraceUtil[pool-3-thread-1]: [0baec503-851f-44e4-9fa8-57b79002a0fb]


- Agetian

Hi first i want to thank you for this great project. Its amazing how good it works at the moment. Unfortunately i got a Bug in my last game with the Computer (AI?).




I dont know exactly the cards names but i cast the Horror with my Wizard out of the Opponents (Computer) graveyard. But you can see that he use as target for his power and toughness my graveyard even hes under my control.

If you need more Information just ask me. thanks for this great Tool. I would like to post a screen but it doesnt worked for me or i done something wrong

greetz

Ellokko wrote:Hi first i want to thank you for this great project. Its amazing how good it works at the moment. Unfortunately i got a Bug in my last game with the Computer (AI?).




I dont know exactly the cards names but i cast the Horror with my Wizard out of the Opponents (Computer) graveyard. But you can see that he use as target for his power and toughness my graveyard even hes under my control.

If you need more Information just ask me. thanks for this great Tool. I would like to post a screen but it doesnt worked for me or i done something wrong

greetz

Yes it would be helpful if you can describe the exact cardnames and steps you take. Maybe you can post the game log, that is probably saved automaticall to the Mage.client/gamelogs/ folder.

??10:24 PokaYoke has joined the game

Match score:
- PokaYoke (0 wins / 0 losses)
- computer (0 wins / 0 losses)

2 wins needed to win the match

Game has started

??10:24 PokaYoke won the toss
??10:24 PokaYoke will start
??10:24 PokaYoke draws 7 cards
??10:24 computer draws 7 cards
??10:24 PokaYoke keeps hand
??10:24 computer keeps hand
??10:24 Turn 1 PokaYoke (20 - 20)
??10:24 PokaYoke plays Watery Grave
??10:24 Turn 2 computer (20 - 20)
??10:24 computer draws 1 card
??10:25 computer plays Island
??10:25 computer casts Jace's Phantasm
??10:25 Turn 3 PokaYoke (20 - 20)
??10:25 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:25 PokaYoke plays Drowned Catacomb
??10:25 Turn 4 computer (20 - 20)
??10:25 computer draws 1 card
??10:26 computer plays Swamp
??10:26 computer casts Duskmantle Guildmage
??10:26 computer attacks with 1 creatures
??10:26 Attacked player: PokaYoke
??10:26 Jace's Phantasm (1/1) unblocked
??10:26 Turn 5 PokaYoke (20 - 19)
??10:26 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:26 PokaYoke plays Nephalia Drownyard
??10:26 PokaYoke casts Chromatic Lantern
??10:27 Turn 6 computer (20 - 19)
??10:27 computer draws 1 card
??10:27 computer plays Swamp
??10:27 computer attacks with 2 creatures
??10:27 Attacked player: PokaYoke
??10:27 Jace's Phantasm (1/1) unblocked
??10:27 Duskmantle Guildmage (2/2) unblocked
??10:27 Turn 7 PokaYoke (20 - 16)
??10:27 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:28 PokaYoke plays Drowned Catacomb
??10:28 PokaYoke casts Trading Post
??10:29 Turn 8 computer (20 - 16)
??10:29 computer draws 1 card
??10:29 computer plays Swamp
??10:29 PokaYoke discards Swamp
??10:29 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Discard card: You gain 4 life. from Trading Post
??10:30 computer activates {U}{B}: Whenever a card is put into an opponent's graveyard from anywhere this turn, that player loses 1 life. from Duskmantle Guildmage
??10:30 computer attacks with 2 creatures
??10:30 Attacked player: PokaYoke
??10:30 Jace's Phantasm (1/1) unblocked
??10:30 Duskmantle Guildmage (2/2) unblocked
??10:30 Turn 9 PokaYoke (20 - 17)
??10:30 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:31 PokaYoke plays Swamp
??10:31 PokaYoke discards Swamp
??10:31 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Discard card: You gain 4 life. from Trading Post
??10:31 Turn 10 computer (20 - 21)
??10:31 computer draws 1 card
??10:32 computer attacks with 2 creatures
??10:32 Attacked player: PokaYoke
??10:32 Jace's Phantasm (1/1) unblocked
??10:32 Duskmantle Guildmage (2/2) unblocked
??10:32 Turn 11 PokaYoke (20 - 18)
??10:32 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:33 PokaYoke plays Swamp
??10:33 PokaYoke casts Mutilate
??10:33 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Pay 1 life: Put a a 0/1 white Goat creature token onto the battlefield. from Trading Post
??10:34 Turn 12 computer (20 - 17)
??10:34 computer draws 1 card
??10:35 Turn 13 PokaYoke (20 - 17)
??10:35 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:35 PokaYoke attacks with 0 creatures
??10:36 Turn 14 computer (20 - 17)
??10:36 computer draws 1 card
??10:37 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Pay 1 life: Put a a 0/1 white Goat creature token onto the battlefield. from Trading Post
??10:37 PokaYoke activates {U}{B},{T}: Target player puts the top three cards of his or her library into his or her graveyard. from Nephalia Drownyard targeting computer
??10:38 computer discards Jace, Memory Adept
??10:38 computer discards 1 card (cleanup)
??10:38 Turn 15 PokaYoke (20 - 16)
??10:38 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:39 PokaYoke casts Nightveil Specter
??10:40 PokaYoke sacrificed Chromatic Lantern
??10:40 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Sacrifice artifact: Draw a card. from Trading Post
??10:40 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:40 PokaYoke plays Swamp
??10:40 PokaYoke activates {U}{B},{T}: Target player puts the top three cards of his or her library into his or her graveyard. from Nephalia Drownyard targeting computer
??10:40 PokaYoke attacks with 0 creatures
??10:40 Turn 16 computer (20 - 16)
??10:40 computer draws 1 card
??10:41 computer discards Consuming Aberration
??10:41 computer discards 1 card (cleanup)
??10:41 Turn 17 PokaYoke (20 - 16)
??10:42 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:42 PokaYoke plays Swamp
??10:42 PokaYoke sacrificed Goat
??10:42 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Sacrifice creature: Return target artifact card in your graveyard to your hand. from Trading Post targeting Chromatic Lantern
??10:42 PokaYoke returned Chromatic Lantern from graveyard to hand
??10:42 PokaYoke casts Chromatic Lantern
??10:43 PokaYoke attacks with 1 creatures
??10:43 Attacked player: computer
??10:43 Nightveil Specter (2/3) unblocked
??10:43 Nightveil Specter triggered ability resolves: Whenever Nightveil Specter deals damage to a player, that player exiles the top card of his or her library.
??10:44 Turn 18 computer (18 - 16)
??10:44 computer draws 1 card
??10:45 PokaYoke activates {U}{B},{T}: Target player puts the top three cards of his or her library into his or her graveyard. from Nephalia Drownyard targeting computer
??10:47 computer discards Jace, Memory Adept
??10:47 computer discards 1 card (cleanup)
??10:47 Turn 19 PokaYoke (18 - 16)
??10:47 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:47 PokaYoke plays Watery Grave
??10:47 PokaYoke casts Prophetic Prism
??10:48 Prophetic Prism triggered ability resolves: When Prophetic Prism enters the battlefield, draw a card.
??10:48 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:48 PokaYoke casts Chromatic Lantern
??10:48 PokaYoke attacks with 1 creatures
??10:49 Attacked player: computer
??10:49 Nightveil Specter (2/3) unblocked
??10:49 Nightveil Specter triggered ability resolves: Whenever Nightveil Specter deals damage to a player, that player exiles the top card of his or her library.
??10:51 PokaYoke sacrificed Prophetic Prism
??10:51 PokaYoke activates ,{T}, Sacrifice artifact: Draw a card. from Trading Post
??10:51 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:51 Turn 20 computer (14 - 16)
??10:51 computer draws 1 card
??10:53 PokaYoke activates {U}{B},{T}: Target player puts the top three cards of his or her library into his or her graveyard. from Nephalia Drownyard targeting computer
??10:53 computer discards Mind Grind
??10:53 computer discards 1 card (cleanup)
??10:53 Turn 21 PokaYoke (14 - 16)
??10:53 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:54 PokaYoke casts Havengul Lich
??10:55 PokaYoke casts Undercity Informer
??10:55 PokaYoke attacks with 1 creatures
??10:56 Attacked player: computer
??10:56 Nightveil Specter (2/3) unblocked
??10:56 Nightveil Specter triggered ability resolves: Whenever Nightveil Specter deals damage to a player, that player exiles the top card of his or her library.
??10:56 Turn 22 computer (12 - 16)
??10:56 computer draws 1 card
??10:58 computer discards Island
??10:58 computer discards 1 card (cleanup)
??10:58 Turn 23 PokaYoke (12 - 16)
??10:58 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??10:58 PokaYoke activates : You may cast target creature card in a graveyard this turn. When you cast that card this turn, Havengul Lich gains all activated abilities of that card until end of turn. from Havengul Lich targeting Consuming Aberration
??10:59 PokaYoke casts Consuming Aberration from graveyard
??10:59 Havengul Lich triggered ability resolves: When you cast that card this turn, Havengul Lich gains all activated abilities of that card until end of turn.
??11:00 PokaYoke attacks with 3 creatures
??11:01 Attacked player: computer
??11:01 Nightveil Specter (2/3) unblocked
??11:01 Havengul Lich (4/4) unblocked
??11:01 Undercity Informer (2/3) unblocked
??11:01 Nightveil Specter triggered ability resolves: Whenever Nightveil Specter deals damage to a player, that player exiles the top card of his or her library.
??11:01 Turn 24 computer (4 - 16)
??11:01 computer draws 1 card
??11:02 computer discards Island
??11:02 computer discards 1 card (cleanup)
??11:02 Turn 25 PokaYoke (4 - 16)
??11:04 PokaYoke draws 1 card
??11:04 PokaYoke attacks with 4 creatures
??11:04 Attacked player: computer
??11:04 Nightveil Specter (2/3) unblocked
??11:04 Havengul Lich (4/4) unblocked
??11:04 Consuming Aberration (4/4) unblocked
??11:04 Undercity Informer (2/3) unblocked
??11:04 computer has lost the game.
??11:04 PokaYoke has won the game


The cards i meant are havengul lich and Consuming Abberration. As i said if you can tell me how to post an image i can show you the screenshot. I always get the message my post is too spamy and i have to remove the URLS ?

This log is enough for me to check the problem. Thanks.

Concerning the screenshot I guess there is a limit of posts you must have done, before you can add it to your post.
But ist very low I guess (probably 3 or 5 posts).

Ok if you need the screenshot tell me and i send you the link as PM

Full Moon's Rise does not give trample to your werewolves

When target human player press cancel button in response to Karn's Liberated first ability "+4: Target player exiles a card from his or her hand.", he doesn't exile anything from his hand.

Spinal Embrace has wrong casting cost 3U instead 3UUB.

Oloro, Ageless Ascetic second ability (Whenever you gain life, you may pay . If you do, draw a card and each opponent loses 1 life.) doesn't trigger during it's own upkeep lifegain (during other situations also - spinal embrace creature sacrifice for example). There's also Ajani Pridemates on the battlefield which triggers properly.

AI very rare casts Commander. And also it casts Curse of Shallow Graves on itself (instead of casting fearsome commander). I think it's unwise.

Triadasoul wrote:AI very rare casts Commander. And also it casts Curse of Shallow Graves on itself (instead of casting fearsome commander). I think it's unwise.

I canged the outcome of Curse of Shallow Graves to negative, so the AI should target an opponent.
The overall behaviour of the AI isn't that smart and not easy to change because it's no proper code. Also is the AI currently (maybe never) not in my focus.