Collectible Card Game Headquarters

04:09: RainbowDash attacks with 1 creature
04:09: Ability triggers: Mavren Fein, Dusk Apostle [8ea] - Whenever one or more nontoken Vampires you control attack, create a 1/1 white Vampire creature token with lifelink.
04:09: absurdo creates a Vampire [8bc] token

I attacked with a vampire and my opponents Mavren Fein triggered somehow.

TheElk801: Fixed beyond 1.4.26V5

First time using this forum. Not sure about navigation. It told me to post this on a specific page, but that page was null.

Brief summary: I was playing against a Human player BootsP if that mattered. My name is yeldnil0 if that consequently mattered. We were doing a Sealed Draft of Ixalan. I played the card Sunbird's Invocation, passed the turn. Then drew Ravenous Daggertooth on my following turn and tried to cast it. I paid for it and it went on the stack. It triggered the Sunbird's Invocation, but immediately brought up an error which I will post below. After closing the error box, it put me to the next step of the game and removed everything from the stack and untapped the sources that I had tapped to pay for it. The error box said that it would rollback, but it pushed it forward instead. I thought that I should bring that part up, too. Alright, here is the text from the error box, I hope that this helps you improve the software, and thank you for bringing this to us. I have put the message in a text document because it won't let me post the text in here because I am a new user and it "looks too spamy".

TheElk801: Fixed beyond 1.4.26V5

Exile effects with durations (i.e. Grasp of Fate, Hostage Taker, etc.) don't work properly:

1. If the permanent leaves the battlefield while the trigger is on the stack, the nonland permanents will still be exiled and will stay exiled.

TheElk801: I can't recreate this. Can you give more details on how you encountered it?

2. If the owner of the permanent leaves the game after the artifact/creature is exiled, the artifact/creature will stay exiled.

MMLgamer wrote:Exile effects with durations (i.e. Grasp of Fate, Hostage Taker, etc.) don't work properly:

1. If the permanent leaves the battlefield while the trigger is on the stack, the nonland permanents will still be exiled and will stay exiled.

TheElk801: I can't recreate this. Can you give more details on how you encountered it?

2. If the owner of the permanent leaves the game after the artifact/creature is exiled, the artifact/creature will stay exiled.

1. This only happened once and I don't have the details, so nvm.
2. Were you able to recreate this?

Bellowing Aegisaur incorrectly triggers multiple times when it gets double blocked (should be only one instance of damage being dealt).

TheElk801: This is a known issue, currently no ETA on a fix

MMLgamer wrote:2. Were you able to recreate this?

I didn't try, but only because I believe it without having to. I put it up as an issue on github, hopefully LevelX2 or someone else will be able to confirm/fix it.

MMLgamer wrote:Exile effects with durations (i.e. Grasp of Fate, Hostage Taker, etc.) don't work properly:

1. If the permanent leaves the battlefield while the trigger is on the stack, the nonland permanents will still be exiled and will stay exiled.

2. If the owner of the permanent leaves the game after the artifact/creature is exiled, the artifact/creature will stay exiled.

Fairly sure that 2. is actually the correct behavior, as frustrating as it might appear. See http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/magi ... ultiplayer
For 1., are you talking about the old trick with sacrificing the exiling permanent before its ETB resolves? (example: Fiend Hunter drops, and I sac him to Ashnod's Altar before he exiles a creature, therefore he exiles a creature forever) Or something else?

It's true for Oblivion Ring and Fiend Hunter, but starting with Banisher Priest a new effect was designed to prevent that kind of issue. Note that the old cards had two separate triggers while the new ones only have one.

TheElk801 wrote:It's true for Oblivion Ring and Fiend Hunter, but starting with Banisher Priest a new effect was designed to prevent that kind of issue. Note that the old cards had two separate triggers while the new ones only have one.

Spell Queller also uses the old templating with two separate triggers.

I specifically said "exile effects with durations" which are different from "exile effects on permanents with 'leave the battlefield' triggers."

Hello,
thank you for the great content you provide with XMage. My Question is: I have been playing about 30 Ixalan Sealed Pools and i never got or played against one of the rare flip enchantments. How does this come? Just a very unlikely coincidence or an error in the system?

Thank you.

TheElk801: Fixed beyond 1.4.26V5

Kill my scarab god that my opponent stole with Gonti and then when it came into my hand i could not cast it.

Added the log file thanks.

TheElk801 wrote:

marcovitch wrote:I have issue with lengendary lands such as urborg, tomb of yawgmoth or flagstones of trokair.
When I play a second copy, it stacks on the first one on the battlefield, and I can't select which one I want to sac : it always selects the second copy.

I tried to recreate this and didn't have a problem selecting one. Are you selecting the one you want to keep or the one you want to get rid of? You're supposed to select the one you want to keep.

hum... you're right ! It's been for many monthes that i was choosing the one to sac...
sorry for disturbance,
thanx for your answer !

Shipwreck Looter asks to select an opponent while putting its raid trigger on the stack. The loot effect does resolve correctly (the controller gets to loot, not the opponent).

I think this is the offending piece of code (line 63):

Code: Select all

        ability.addTarget(new TargetOpponent());

TheElk801: Fixed beyond 1.4.26V5

Atarka, World Render ability "Whenever Dragons you control attack, they get Double Strike until end of turn" does not trigger when I attack with dragon creatures in the newest Xmage iteration 1.4.26V5
Best regards and merry week

TheElk801: Fixed beyond 1.4.26V5