In 4 player EDH, all human players, one player had conceded and 3 of us continued playing. I don't have a screencap of boardstate unfortunately, but I'll try to recount most of the relevant information here.
- If it's relevant, I had the Ultimate emblem from Elspeth, Kight-Errant.
- The player who quit had cast a board wipe before quitting, so only I had creatures remaining:
Goblin Electromancer,
Maralen of the Mornsong, and
Galecaster Colossus.
- I had a
Marchesa, the Black Rose in play before the board wipe, which an opponent took with
Simic Manipulator.
- I used the
Galecaster Colossus's ability to return Marchesa to my hand before the wipe.
- On my next turn, I cast her, and she entered the battlefield under the control of the opponent who had taken her with Simic manipulator.
I'm fairly new to magic, but I didn't think this was how it was supposed to work. Is my understanding incorrect, or is this a bug?
TheElk801: Fixed beyond 1.4.26V8