Collectible Card Game Headquarters

I haven't played xmage in a while but I noticed that now gonti lord of luxury does not work. I cannot cast the cards that are exiled with him.

jeffwadsworth: It worked fine with Gonti on the battlefield and off for me with the latest build. Please provide a game log.

When a creature with Nighthowler attatched gets enchanted with Song of the Dryads, Nightholwer doesn't become a creature and gets turned into a card without stats.

LevelX: Fixed beyond 1.4.27V3

Revotor wrote:jeffwadsworth: 611.3c Continuous effects that modify characteristics of permanents do so simultaneously with the permanent entering the battlefield. They don’t wait until the permanent is on the battlefield and then change it. Because such effects apply as the permanent enters the battlefield, they are applied before determining whether the permanent will cause an ability to trigger when it enters the battlefield.

We know about it but it hasn't been implemented yet. It applies to more than just lands.

You are wrong. Looking that:

If a land has an ability that causes it to enter the battlefield tapped, it will lose that ability before it applies. The same is also true of any other abilities of a land that modify how it enters the battlefield or apply “as” it enters the battlefield, such as the first ability of Unclaimed Territory.

Source: Gatherer.


jeffwadsworth: Example: A permanent with the static ability “All white creatures get +1/+1” is on the battlefield. A creature spell that would normally create a 1/1 white creature instead creates a 2/2 white creature. The creature doesn’t enter the battlefield as 1/1 and then change to 2/2.

Hi, Right but, I'm not saying this for annoying. The rules changed for the lands, if you want the official source, you can check the gatherer.

Lands with blood Sun enter in the battlefield Untapped.



jeffwadsworth: Why do you think that Rule 611.3c applies to lands only? Because Gatherer lists a an example that has a land? What do you think Humility would do to a creature card entering the battlefield with an "Enters the Battlefield" trigger or ability?
Here something to read if you want a source:
https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/a ... 2017-09-28

Currently the effect of Nature's Will triggers at the beginning of the postcombat main phase which is fine most of the time, but if creatures have double strike or an effect like Aurelia, the Warleader grants extra combat phases, the trigger from Nature's Will should happen multiple times before the main phase.

LevelX: Fixed beyond 1.4.27V0

Hi
I think the citys blessing isnt working right with Tilonalli's Summoner. I get the City's Blessing and end of turn my tokens were exiled.
the blessing should stay (anyway if i loose some permanents) and the tokens too.
Thanks for your work
Lurro99

LevelX: Fixed beyond 1.4.27V2

Playing a 3-player EDH game, 2 AI opponents (computer-mad)
Opponent plays Forgotten Ancient, the turn goes around the table, I pass to the opponent, Forgotten Ancient triggers on their upkeep and goes on the stack.

The UI indicates that I have priority to respond with instants/abilities, even though I have no answers. My timer is going down and there seems to be no natural way past that (I haven't tried the skip buttons yet).



JayDi: It's known bug with priority lost (all player wait each other) -- may be can help skip turn button. We hope it will be fixed on next release.

Hello it appears that you can pitch a blue card on Force of Will flashbacked with Snapcaster Mage.
An opponent did it but didnt respond when I noticed that he couldn't normally do this.

| Open

117.9a Only one alternative cost can be applied to any one spell as it's being cast. The controller of the spell announces his or her intentions to pay that cost as described in rule 601.2b.
702.32a Flashback appears on some instants and sorceries. It represents two static abilities: one that functions while the card is in a player's graveyard and the other that functions while the card is on the stack. "Flashback [cost]" means "You may cast this card from your graveyard by paying [cost] rather than paying its mana cost" and "If the flashback cost was paid, exile this card instead of putting it anywhere else any time it would leave the stack." Casting a spell using its flashback ability follows the rules for paying alternative costs in rules 601.2b and 601.2e-g.

LevelX: Fixed beyond 1.4.27V4b

I played a land to get myself to 10 permanents, but Ascend didn't trigger for my (in play) Arch of Orazca. Notice in the attached image that you can see me play my 10th permanent in the chat log, but no City's Blessing trigger, and my land would still only tap for {c} afterward.

The only notable features of my permanents were that the Glorybringer was cast off a Chandra +1 trigger, which might have caused it to get treated oddly. Also, the Chandra, Torch of Defiance was (temporarily) exiled by a Kitesail Freebooter before being recovered and cast.

Here's the full match log: | Open

12:52 AM: Zerris has joined the game
12:52 AM: AlphaGIANT has joined the game
: Match score: AlphaGIANT - 0 wins DeckHash: 6265656369307653807 Zerris - 0 wins DeckHash: 5450055458029554854 Match is not rated You have to win 2 games to win the complete match Game has started
12:52 AM: AlphaGIANT won the toss
12:52 AM: Zerris's library is shuffled
12:52 AM: AlphaGIANT's library is shuffled
12:52 AM: AlphaGIANT chooses that he or she takes the first turn
12:52 AM: AlphaGIANT draws seven cards
12:52 AM: Zerris draws seven cards
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT decides to take mulligan
12:53 AM: Zerris decides to take mulligan
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT's library is shuffled
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT mulligans down to 6 cards
12:53 AM: Zerris's library is shuffled
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT draws six cards
12:53 AM: Zerris draws six cards
12:53 AM: Zerris mulligans down to 6 cards
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT keeps hand
12:53 AM: Zerris keeps hand
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT scries 1
12:53 AM: Zerris scries 1
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library to the bottom of his or her library
12:53 AM: Zerris puts a card from library to the bottom of his or her library
12:53 AM: Turn 1 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Field of Ruin [65b] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT plays Field of Ruin [65b]
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
12:53 AM: Turn 2 Zerris (20 - 20)
12:53 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:53 AM: Zerris plays Swamp [5b1]
12:53 AM: Zerris puts Swamp [5b1] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:53 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
12:53 AM: Turn 3 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
12:53 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
12:54 AM: Turn 4 Zerris (20 - 20)
12:54 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:54 AM: Zerris puts Swamp [8e4] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:54 AM: Zerris plays Swamp [8e4]
12:54 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
12:54 AM: Turn 5 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Swamp [104] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT plays Swamp [104]
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Harsh Scrutiny [804] targeting Zerris
12:54 AM: Zerris reveals Rekindling Phoenix, Abrade, Sweltering Suns, Fatal Push, Chandra, Torch of Defiance, Sweltering Suns
12:54 AM: Zerris discards Rekindling Phoenix [de2]
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT scries 1
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library to the bottom of his or her library
12:54 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Harsh Scrutiny [804] from stack into his or her graveyard
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
12:55 AM: Turn 6 Zerris (20 - 20)
12:55 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:55 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
12:55 AM: Turn 7 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Lay Bare the Heart [3d3] targeting Zerris
12:55 AM: Zerris reveals Abrade, Sweltering Suns, Fatal Push, Chandra, Torch of Defiance, Sweltering Suns, Sweltering Suns
12:55 AM: Zerris discards Abrade [2ca]
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Lay Bare the Heart [3d3] from stack into his or her graveyard
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
12:55 AM: Turn 8 Zerris (20 - 20)
12:55 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:55 AM: Zerris puts Arch of Orazca [c1a] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:55 AM: Zerris plays Arch of Orazca [c1a]
12:55 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
12:55 AM: Turn 9 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [356]
12:55 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [356] from stack onto the Battlefield
12:55 AM: Ability triggers: Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [356] - Whenever Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [356] enters the battlefield or attacks, you get (an energy counter).
12:56 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
12:56 AM: Zerris discards Sweltering Suns [007]
12:56 AM: Zerris activates: draw a card. from Sweltering Suns [007]
12:56 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:56 AM: Turn 10 Zerris (20 - 20)
12:56 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:56 AM: Zerris puts Canyon Slough [2bb] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:56 AM: Zerris plays Canyon Slough [2bb]
12:56 AM: Zerris casts Fatal Push [df8] targeting Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [356]
12:56 AM: Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [356] died
12:56 AM: Zerris puts Fatal Push [df8] from stack into his or her graveyard
12:56 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
12:56 AM: Turn 11 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:56 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
12:56 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Kitesail Freebooter [da8]
12:56 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Kitesail Freebooter [da8] from stack onto the Battlefield
12:56 AM: Ability triggers: Kitesail Freebooter [da8] - When Kitesail Freebooter [da8] enters the battlefield, target opponent reveals his or her hand. You choose a noncreature, nonland card from it. Exile that card until Kitesail Freebooter [da8] leaves the battlefield. - targeting Zerris
12:56 AM: Zerris reveals Sweltering Suns, Chandra, Torch of Defiance, Sweltering Suns, Vraska's Contempt
12:56 AM: AlphaGIANT moves Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] from hand to the exile zone
12:56 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
12:57 AM: Turn 12 Zerris (20 - 20)
12:57 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:57 AM: Zerris puts Mountain [216] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:57 AM: Zerris plays Mountain [216]
12:57 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
12:57 AM: Turn 13 AlphaGIANT (20 - 20)
12:57 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
12:57 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Harsh Scrutiny [559] targeting Zerris
12:57 AM: Zerris reveals Sweltering Suns, Sweltering Suns, Vraska's Contempt
12:57 AM: AlphaGIANT scries 1
12:58 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library to the bottom of his or her library
12:58 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Harsh Scrutiny [559] from stack into his or her graveyard
12:58 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 1 creature
12:58 AM: Attacker: Kitesail Freebooter [da8] (1/2) unblocked
12:58 AM: Zerris loses 1 life
12:58 AM: Zerris casts Vraska's Contempt [cae] targeting Kitesail Freebooter [da8]
12:58 AM: Zerris moves Kitesail Freebooter [da8] from battlefield to the exile zone
12:58 AM: Zerris gains 2 life
12:58 AM: Zerris puts Vraska's Contempt [cae] from stack into his or her graveyard
12:58 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] from exile zone into its owner's hand
12:58 AM: Turn 14 Zerris (21 - 20)
12:58 AM: Zerris draws a card
12:58 AM: Zerris casts Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447]
12:58 AM: Zerris puts Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] from stack onto the Battlefield
12:59 AM: Zerris puts Ifnir Deadlands [bc8] from hand onto the Battlefield
12:59 AM: Zerris plays Ifnir Deadlands [bc8]
1:00 AM: Zerris activates: Exile the top card of your library. You may cast that card. If you don't, Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] deals 2 damage to each opponent. from Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447]
1:00 AM: Zerris moves Dragonskull Summit [4ec] from library to the exile zone
1:00 AM: AlphaGIANT loses 2 life
1:00 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
1:00 AM: Turn 15 AlphaGIANT (21 - 18)
1:03 AM: AlphaGIANT has rejoined the game
1:03 AM: AlphaGIANT has rejoined the game
1:03 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
1:04 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [8f1]
1:05 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [8f1] from stack onto the Battlefield
1:05 AM: Ability triggers: Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [8f1] - Whenever Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [8f1] enters the battlefield or attacks, you get (an energy counter).
1:05 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
1:05 AM: Turn 16 Zerris (21 - 18)
1:05 AM: Zerris draws a card
1:05 AM: Zerris puts Mountain [dec] from hand onto the Battlefield
1:05 AM: Zerris plays Mountain [dec]
1:05 AM: Zerris activates: Exile the top card of your library. You may cast that card. If you don't, Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] deals 2 damage to each opponent. from Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447]
1:05 AM: Zerris moves Scavenger Grounds [88a] from library to the exile zone
1:05 AM: AlphaGIANT loses 2 life
1:05 AM: Zerris casts Sweltering Suns [a88]
1:05 AM: Sweltering Suns [a88] deals 3 damage to Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [8f1]
1:05 AM: Zerris puts Sweltering Suns [a88] from stack into his or her graveyard
1:05 AM: Glint-Sleeve Siphoner [8f1] died
1:05 AM: Zerris attacks with 0 creatures
1:05 AM: Turn 17 AlphaGIANT (21 - 16)
1:05 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
1:05 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Swamp [3e8] from hand onto the Battlefield
1:05 AM: AlphaGIANT plays Swamp [3e8]
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Sword-Point Diplomacy [cf2]
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT reveals Torment of Scarabs, Lay Bare the Heart, Field of Ruin
1:06 AM: Zerris loses 3 life
1:06 AM: Zerris loses 3 life
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library into his or her hand
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT moves Torment of Scarabs [52b] from library to the exile zone
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT moves Lay Bare the Heart [05c] from library to the exile zone
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Sword-Point Diplomacy [cf2] from stack into his or her graveyard
1:06 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
1:06 AM: Turn 18 Zerris (15 - 16)
1:06 AM: Zerris draws a card
1:06 AM: Zerris activates: Exile the top card of your library. You may cast that card. If you don't, Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] deals 2 damage to each opponent. from Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447]
1:06 AM: Zerris moves Glorybringer [297] from library to the exile zone
1:07 AM: Zerris casts Glorybringer [297]
1:07 AM: Zerris puts Glorybringer [297] from stack onto the Battlefield
1:07 AM: Zerris attacks with 1 creature
1:07 AM: Attacker: Glorybringer [297] (4/4) unblocked
1:07 AM: AlphaGIANT loses 4 life
1:07 AM: Turn 19 AlphaGIANT (15 - 12)
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT draws a card
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT plays Field of Ruin [654]
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Field of Ruin [654] from hand onto the Battlefield
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT casts Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8]
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT puts Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8] from stack onto the Battlefield
1:08 AM: Ability triggers: Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8] - When Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8] enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of target opponent's library, exile one of them face down, then put the rest on the bottom of that library in a random order. For as long as that card remains exiled, you may look at it, you may cast it, and you may spend mana as though it were mana of any type to cast it. - targeting Zerris
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library to the bottom of Zerris's library
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT moves a card face down from library to the exile zone
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library to the bottom of Zerris's library
1:08 AM: AlphaGIANT puts a card from library to the bottom of Zerris's library
1:09 AM: AlphaGIANT attacks with 0 creatures
1:09 AM: Turn 20 Zerris (15 - 12)
1:09 AM: Zerris draws a card
1:09 AM: Zerris puts Dragonskull Summit [75e] from hand onto the Battlefield
1:09 AM: Zerris plays Dragonskull Summit [75e]
1:10 AM: Zerris exerted Glorybringer
1:10 AM: Zerris attacks with 1 creature
1:10 AM: Ability triggers: Glorybringer [297] - When Glorybringer [297] becomes exerted, it deals 4 damage to target non-Dragon creature an opponent controls. - targeting Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8]
1:12 AM: Glorybringer [297] deals 4 damage to Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8]
1:12 AM: Gonti, Lord of Luxury [0f8] died
1:12 AM: Attacker: Glorybringer [297] (4/4) unblocked
1:12 AM: AlphaGIANT loses 4 life
1:12 AM: Zerris activates: You get an emblem with "Whenever you cast a spell, this emblem deals 5 damage to target creature or player." from Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447]
1:12 AM: Chandra, Torch of Defiance [447] is put into graveyard from battlefield
1:12 AM: Zerris casts Sweltering Suns [b00]
1:13 AM: AlphaGIANT has conceded.
1:13 AM: AlphaGIANT has lost the game.

LevelX: Fixed beyond 1.4.27V0

so im having trouble just remaining connected for 2 minutes after connecting to the server. ive tried to connect to the 3 servers and it happens on each one. i dont think its my connection cuz i dont lag on any of my other games, my javas up to date and so is xmage. ive even forced updated xmage to be sure

EDIT: and now it freezes when i open the client. and sorry cant get a screen shot

Seconding Sinagelj's complaint, minus the freezing bit.
Issue started only today for me. Multiple servers all produce this bizarre behavior of kicking me off after a few minutes, then refusing to reconnect.
First couple of times it happened, just figured the servers had legit hiccups, but hours later the problem persists, and feels like something else may well be at issue here.
Guesses, anyone?

As usual, 3-player EDH game with 2 computer-mad opponents.
Opponent plays Night Soil, proceeds to activate its ability. The log shows they exiled Mistmeadow Witch (a creature) and a Terramorphic Expanse (a land) from another player's graveyard to create a Saproling, while the cost requires creature cards specifically.

Attached pic of the ability on the stack and partial log.

EDIT: the AI player repeated this ability, now exiling Etherium Sculptor and Carnage Altar from 2 different graveyards, so not only card type isn't checked, neither is the ownership of the graveyard.

Code: Select all

9:55 AM: computer moves Etherium Sculptor [1fa] from graveyard to the exile zone
9:55 AM: computer moves Carnage Altar [4e1] from graveyard to the exile zone
9:55 AM: computer activates: create a 1/1 green Saproling creature token. from Night Soil [019]

Spreading Seas is bugged, opp casted it on my Field of Ruin, I sacced with the spell on stack but it resolved anyway and let him draw.

LevelX: I can't reproduce the problem. As the target does no longer exits during resolving Spreading Seas, Spreading Seas is counterd correctly.

Card: Slaughter the Strong

Expected: Each player picks any number of creatures with combined power 4 or less.

Reality: Complete FUBAR. Owner of Slaughter gets to select creatures as normal. This selection seems to count against every other player's choice (Sum of power). One time, no one got to pick any creatures.

issue on multiple card: when i try to join a room, or create my own i receive a server error="card name" null