didi wrote:Hoac wrote:There seems to be a bug related to
Chaos Warp. If you
Chaos Warp your commander, and choose to put it into the command zone, the top card of your library should be put into play. However, the library was shuffled when I tried it.
- | Open
- <font color="#CCCC33">15:48: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
searches their library</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:48: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">'s
library is shuffled</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:48: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts a card from library to the top of their library</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
casts </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh">Nicol
Bolas, God-Pharaoh</a></font><font color="White"> [d35]</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh">Nicol
Bolas, God-Pharaoh</a></font><font color="White"> [d35] from stack onto
the Battlefield</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
casts </font><font color="#FF6347"><a href="#Chaos Warp">Chaos Warp</a></font><font color="White">
[bdb] targeting </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#The Ur-Dragon">The
Ur-Dragon</a></font><font color="White"> [577] </font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
has moved their commander to the command zone</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#The Ur-Dragon">The Ur-Dragon</a></font><font color="White">
[577] from battlefield to the top of their library</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">'s
library is shuffled</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
reveals </font><font color="#87CEFA">Jace, Memory Adept</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#87CEFA"><a href="#Jace, Memory Adept">Jace,
Memory Adept</a></font><font color="White"> [e91] from library onto the
Battlefield</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">15:49: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#FF6347"><a href="#Chaos Warp">Chaos Warp</a></font><font color="White">
[bdb] from stack into their graveyard</font>
It ain't no bug. Your commander isn't being shuffled into your library. So you're fizzling your own [
Chaos Warp] instead of comboing.
I was wrong, the library is shuffled even if the replacement effect occurs.
Chaos Warp works as intended.
609.3 If an effect attempts to do something impossible, it does only as much as possible.
701.19c If an effect would cause a player to shuffle one or more specific objects into a library, that library is shuffled even if none of those objects are in the zone they’re expected to be in or an effect causes all of those objects to be moved to another zone or remain in their current zone.
Different bug report.
Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh 's +1 ability doesn't seem to force opponents to exile 2 cards from their hands. They can simply skip the exile effect.
- | Open
- <font color="#CCCC33">19:13: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
casts </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh">Nicol
Bolas, God-Pharaoh</a></font><font color="White"> [3c6]</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:13: </font><font color="White">Ability triggers: </font><font color="#87CEFA"><a href="#Memory Erosion">Memory
Erosion</a></font><font color="White"> [c7d] - Whenever an opponent casts
a spell, that player puts the top two cards of their library into their
graveyard</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:13: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#B0C4DE"><a href="#Reflecting Pool">Reflecting
Pool</a></font><font color="White"> [c00] from library into their graveyard</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:13: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#87CEFA"><a href="#Chain of Vapor">Chain of Vapor</a></font><font color="White">
[2aa] from library into their graveyard</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:14: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh">Nicol
Bolas, God-Pharaoh</a></font><font color="White"> [3c6] from stack onto
the Battlefield</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:14: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
activates: Each opponent exiles two cards from their hand. from </font><font color="#DAA520"><a href="#Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh">Nicol
Bolas, God-Pharaoh</a></font><font color="White"> [3c6]</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:15: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
attacks with 0 creatures</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:15: </font><font color="White">Ability triggers: </font><font color="#87CEFA"><a href="#Fraying Sanity">Fraying
Sanity</a></font><font color="White"> [d9d] - At the beginning of each end
step, enchanted player puts the top X cards of their library into their
graveyard, where X is the total number of cards put into their graveyard
from anywhere this turn.</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:16: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#696969"><a href="#Vampiric Tutor">Vampiric Tutor</a></font><font color="White">
[afc] from library into their graveyard</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:16: </font><font color="#20B2AA">Hoac</font><font color="White">
puts </font><font color="#B0C4DE"><a href="#Command Tower">Command Tower</a></font><font color="White">
[b0a] from library into their graveyard</font>
<font color="#CCCC33">19:16: </font><font color="Orange">Turn 37 </font><font color="#20B2AA">dickbutt</font><font color="Orange">
(41 - 11 - 45)</font>
Fixed in the next release.