Collectible Card Game Headquarters

Posted: **10 Apr 2019, 11:56**

In the same game with two humans and an AI.

Jeering Homunculus goaded Hanweir Militia Captain.

On the next turn Hanweir Militia Captain transformed into Westvale Cult Leader.
Since a transformed object is still the same object should it not still be goaded.
Yet the AI chose not to attack with it.

Posted: **10 Apr 2019, 12:14**

In a different game between the same two human players and AI.

| Open: With Waste Not in play I activated Liliana of the Veil's first loyalty ability causing each player to discard a card.
I chose to discard a Swamp.
The AI chose to discard a Doubtless One.
I discarded the Swamp, the AI discarded the Doubtless One.
Waste Not triggers, putting a zombie into play for me.
The AI's Soul Wardens trigger granting him 2 life.

The third player was never asked to discard a card, it seems this process got interrupted by Waste Not somehow.

Relevant part of the log:
14:07: Turn 10 Tharkon (27 - 18 - 20)
14:07: Tharkon draws a card
14:07: Tharkon puts Swamp [5eb] from hand onto the Battlefield
14:07: Tharkon plays Swamp [5eb]
14:07: Tharkon casts Liliana of the Veil [c71]
14:07: Tharkon puts Liliana of the Veil [c71] from stack onto the Battlefield
14:07: Tharkon activates: each player discards a card. from Liliana of the Veil [c71]
14:07: Tharkon discards Swamp [dc7]
14:07: AI discards Doubtless One [0a5]
14:07: Ability triggers: Waste Not [6c6] - Whenever an opponent discards a creature card, create a 2/2 black Zombie creature token.
14:08: Tharkon creates a Zombie [d5b] token
14:08: Ability triggers: Soul Warden [955] - Whenever another creature enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.
14:08: Ability triggers: Soul Warden [66f] - Whenever another creature enters the battlefield, you gain 1 life.
14:08: AI gains 1 life
14:08: AI gains 1 life

EDIT: I tried to replicate it without skipping (F9) active and now all three players had to discard a card.
EDIT2: I tried to replicate it with skipping (F9) but still can't replicate the bug, seems to have been a one time thing.

Posted: **14 Apr 2019, 01:01**

In a duel between humans.

I play Savage Stomp on my Cherished Hatchling and have it fight the opponents Edgewalker.
Both creatures die.
Cherished Hatchling's ability triggers.
I play Crested Herdcaller and it gains "When Crested Herdcaller enters the battlefield, you may have it fight another target creature."
However when it enters the battlefield the ability does not trigger and it does not fight a creature.
Its own enter the battlefield trigger does fire.

The same happened when Crested Herdcaller is replaced by Burning Sun's Avatar.

Posted: **14 Apr 2019, 08:21**

AI played Tajuru Preserver which was immediately killed.

AI player was not required to make sacrifices for the entire remainder of the game.

Posted: **14 Apr 2019, 14:31**

In a game between two humans.

I play Jeering Homunculus goading the opponent's Sorceress Queen.
During the opponent's Declare Attackers face he was not required to attack with the Sorceress Queen.
In fact, he was not allowed to.

Game Log
6:29: Turn 13 Envy (13 - 19)
16:29: Ability triggers: Puca's Mischief [e59] - At the beginning of your upkeep, you may exchange control of target nonland permanent you control and target nonland permanent an opponent controls with an equal or lesser converted mana cost. - targeting Shimmering Wings [395] Guul Draz Assassin [9c3]
16:29: Envy draws a card
16:29: Envy casts Jeering Homunculus [b8c]
16:29: Envy puts Jeering Homunculus [b8c] from stack onto the Battlefield
16:29: Ability triggers: Jeering Homunculus [b8c] - When Jeering Homunculus [b8c] enters the battlefield, - targeting Sorceress Queen [010]
16:29: Envy is goading Sorceress Queen [010]
16:29: Envy puts Island [fb8] from hand onto the Battlefield
16:29: Envy plays Island [fb8]
16:29: Envy attacks with 0 creatures
16:29: Turn 14 Perdition (13 - 19)
16:29: Perdition draws a card
16:29: Perdition puts Swamp [c78] from hand onto the Battlefield
16:29: Perdition plays Swamp [c78]
16:30: Perdition attacks with 0 creatures

Posted: **14 Apr 2019, 17:01**

Beta: Ral, Storm Conduit's passive never triggers, if you cast or copy a spell. You never get to choose to deal damage to anyone.

| Open: 18:34: Hoac activates: When you cast your next instant or sorcery spell this turn,
copy that spell. You may choose new targets for the copy. from Ral, Storm Conduit
18:34: Hoac loses 2 life
18:34: Hoac announces a value of 8 for X
18:34: Hoac casts Diabolic Revelation
18:34: Ability triggers: Ral, Storm Conduit - When you cast your
next instant or sorcery spell this turn, copy that spell. You may choose
new targets for the copy.
18:34: Hoac copies Diabolic Revelation
18:34: Hoac searches their library
18:34: Hoac's library is shuffled
18:34: Hoac searches their library
18:35: Hoac's library is shuffled
18:35: Hoac puts Diabolic Revelation from stack into their graveyard

Posted: **14 Apr 2019, 18:30**

Beta: Whenever a loyalty counter is removed from any planeswalker, Chandra, Fire Artisan's passive ability will procc, and you will be able to deal damage. Instead of only triggering, if she loses loyalty counters.

| Open: 19:47: Hoac
casts <a href="#Chandra, Fire Artisan">Chandra,
Fire Artisan</a> [0d1]
19:47: Hoac
puts <a href="#Chandra, Fire Artisan">Chandra,
Fire Artisan</a> [0d1] from stack onto the
Battlefield
19:47: Hoac
activates: until your next turn, up to two target creatures each have base
power and toughness 0/3 and lose all abilities. from <a href="#Will Kenrith">Will
Kenrith</a> [829]
19:47: Ability triggers: <a href="#Emblem Rowan Kenrith">Emblem
Rowan Kenrith</a> [e3a] - Whenever you activate
an ability that isn't a mana ability, copy it. You may choose new targets
for the copy.
19:47: Emblem Rowan Kenrith : Hoac
copied activated ability
19:47: Hoac
activates: until your next turn, up to two target creatures each have base
power and toughness 0/3 and lose all abilities. from <a href="#Will Kenrith">Will
Kenrith</a> [829]
19:47: Ability triggers: <a href="#Emblem Rowan Kenrith">Emblem
Rowan Kenrith</a> [e3a] - Whenever you activate
an ability that isn't a mana ability, copy it. You may choose new targets
for the copy.
19:47: Emblem Rowan Kenrith : Hoac
copied activated ability
19:47: Hoac
activates: until your next turn, up to two target creatures each have base
power and toughness 0/3 and lose all abilities. from <a href="#Will Kenrith">Will
Kenrith</a> [829]
19:47: Ability triggers: <a href="#Emblem Rowan Kenrith">Emblem
Rowan Kenrith</a> [e3a] - Whenever you activate
an ability that isn't a mana ability, copy it. You may choose new targets
for the copy.
19:47: Emblem Rowan Kenrith : Hoac
copied activated ability
19:47: Hoac
activates: target player draws two cards. Until your next turn, instant,
sorcery, and planeswalker spells that player casts cost 2
less to cast. from <a href="#Will Kenrith">Will
Kenrith</a> [829] targeting Hoac

19:47: Ability triggers: <a href="#Chandra, Fire Artisan">Chandra,
Fire Artisan</a> [0d1] - Whenever one or more
loyalty counters are removed from <a href="#Chandra, Fire Artisan">Chandra,
Fire Artisan</a> [0d1], she deals that much
damage to target opponent or planeswalker. - targeting computer

19:47: Ability triggers: <a href="#Emblem Rowan Kenrith">Emblem
Rowan Kenrith</a> [e3a] - Whenever you activate
an ability that isn't a mana ability, copy it. You may choose new targets
for the copy.
19:47: Emblem Rowan Kenrith : Hoac
copied activated ability
19:47: Hoac
draws two cards
19:47: computer
loses 2 life
19:47: Hoac
draws two cards

Posted: **14 Apr 2019, 20:57**

Varchild, Betrayer of Kjeldor is still making tokens for the player that controls it.

Dealt 7 damage to AI, the combat log shows that the AI created the tokens, but the tokens are created on my board.

| Open

I have seen this happen intermittently as well. Mostly when I move back a turn or two and replay it. https://github.com/magefree/mage/issues/5277

Posted: **16 Apr 2019, 15:52**

In game online with human, format Canadian Highlander.

Despite access to black mana source, unable to cast cabal therapy in hand over multiple turns of testing during main phases. Won't even register as clickable in the hand, no highlight, nothing but the ability to reorder it in hand.

See attached game log, not much use.

| Open: <html>
<head>

</head>
<body>
16:07: heptaspud
has joined the game
16:07: nefolaC4
has joined the game
 Match score: heptaspud
- 1 win DeckHash: -581415300066979613 nefolaC4
- 1 win DeckHash: 4483128115850760349 Range: ONE Mulligan type:
Canadian Highlander Free mulligans: 0 Match is not rated You
have to win 2 games to win the complete match Game has started 
16:07: nefolaC4's
library is shuffled
16:07: heptaspud's
library is shuffled
16:07: nefolaC4
chooses that he or she takes the first turn
16:07: nefolaC4
draws seven cards
16:07: heptaspud
draws seven cards
16:07: nefolaC4
keeps hand
16:07: heptaspud
decides to take mulligan
16:07: heptaspud's
library is shuffled
16:07: heptaspud
mulligans to 6 cards
16:07: heptaspud
draws six cards
16:07: heptaspud
decides to take mulligan
16:07: heptaspud's
library is shuffled
16:07: heptaspud
mulligans to 6 cards
16:07: heptaspud
draws six cards
16:07: heptaspud
decides to take mulligan
16:07: heptaspud's
library is shuffled
16:07: heptaspud
mulligans to 5 cards
16:07: heptaspud
draws five cards
16:08: heptaspud
keeps hand
16:08: heptaspud
scries 1
16:08: heptaspud
puts a card from library to the bottom of their library
16:08: Turn 1 nefolaC4
(20 - 20)
16:08: nefolaC4
puts <a href="#Minamo, School at Water's Edge">Minamo,
School at Water's Edge</a> [3e1] from hand onto
the Battlefield
16:08: nefolaC4
plays <a href="#Minamo, School at Water's Edge">Minamo,
School at Water's Edge</a> [3e1]
16:08: nefolaC4
casts <a href="#Sensei's Divining Top">Sensei's
Divining Top</a> [69f]
16:08: nefolaC4
puts <a href="#Sensei's Divining Top">Sensei's
Divining Top</a> [69f] from stack onto the
Battlefield
16:08: nefolaC4
attacks with 0 creatures
16:08: Turn 2 heptaspud
(20 - 20)
16:09: heptaspud
draws a card
16:09: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Misty Rainforest">Misty
Rainforest</a> [0d3] from hand onto the
Battlefield
16:09: heptaspud
plays <a href="#Misty Rainforest">Misty
Rainforest</a> [0d3]
16:09: heptaspud
loses 1 life
16:09: heptaspud
sacrificed <a href="#Misty Rainforest">Misty
Rainforest</a> [0d3]
16:09: heptaspud
activates: search your library for a Forest or Island and put it onto the
battlefield. Then shuffle your library. from <a href="#Misty Rainforest">Misty
Rainforest</a> [0d3]
16:09: heptaspud
searches their library
16:10: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Temple Garden">Temple Garden</a>
[dc8] from library onto the Battlefield
16:10: heptaspud's
library is shuffled
16:10: heptaspud
attacks with 0 creatures
16:10: Turn 3 nefolaC4
(20 - 19)
16:10: nefolaC4
activates: look at the top three cards of your library, then put them back
in any order. from <a href="#Sensei's Divining Top">Sensei's
Divining Top</a> [69f]
16:11: nefolaC4
puts a card from library to the top of their library
16:11: nefolaC4
puts a card from library to the top of their library
16:11: nefolaC4
puts a card from library to the top of their library
16:11: nefolaC4
draws a card
16:11: nefolaC4
puts <a href="#Spire of Industry">Spire of
Industry</a> [861] from hand onto the
Battlefield
16:11: nefolaC4
plays <a href="#Spire of Industry">Spire of
Industry</a> [861]
16:11: nefolaC4
casts <a href="#Chromatic Sphere">Chromatic
Sphere</a> [97c]
16:11: nefolaC4
puts <a href="#Chromatic Sphere">Chromatic
Sphere</a> [97c] from stack onto the Battlefield
16:11: nefolaC4
attacks with 0 creatures
16:11: Turn 4 heptaspud
(20 - 19)
16:11: heptaspud
draws a card
16:11: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Blooming Marsh">Blooming Marsh</a>
[287] from hand onto the Battlefield
16:11: heptaspud
plays <a href="#Blooming Marsh">Blooming Marsh</a>
[287]
16:11: heptaspud
casts <a href="#Fyndhorn Elves">Fyndhorn Elves</a>
[1d4]
16:11: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Fyndhorn Elves">Fyndhorn Elves</a>
[1d4] from stack onto the Battlefield
16:13: heptaspud
attacks with 0 creatures
16:15: heptaspud
casts <a href="#Viscera Seer">Viscera Seer</a>
[955]
16:15: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Viscera Seer">Viscera Seer</a>
[955] from stack onto the Battlefield
16:15: Turn 5 nefolaC4
(20 - 19)
16:15: nefolaC4
draws a card
16:15: nefolaC4
puts <a href="#Glimmervoid">Glimmervoid</a>
[5e7] from hand onto the Battlefield
16:15: nefolaC4
plays <a href="#Glimmervoid">Glimmervoid</a>
[5e7]
16:15: nefolaC4
discards <a href="#Tolaria West">Tolaria West</a>
[82f]
16:15: nefolaC4
activates: Transmute. from <a href="#Tolaria West">Tolaria
West</a> [82f]
16:15: nefolaC4
searches their library
16:15: nefolaC4
reveals Black Lotus
16:15: nefolaC4
puts a card from library into their hand
16:15: nefolaC4's
library is shuffled
16:15: nefolaC4
casts <a href="#Black Lotus">Black Lotus</a>
[a11]
16:15: nefolaC4
puts <a href="#Black Lotus">Black Lotus</a>
[a11] from stack onto the Battlefield
16:15: nefolaC4
attacks with 0 creatures
16:15: Turn 6 heptaspud
(20 - 19)
16:15: heptaspud
draws a card
16:15: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Phyrexian Tower">Phyrexian
Tower</a> [a67] from hand onto the Battlefield
16:15: heptaspud
plays <a href="#Phyrexian Tower">Phyrexian
Tower</a> [a67]
16:20: heptaspud
casts <a href="#Renegade Rallier">Renegade
Rallier</a> [fce]
16:20: heptaspud
puts <a href="#Renegade Rallier">Renegade
Rallier</a> [fce] from stack onto the
Battlefield
16:20: heptaspud
attacks with 0 creatures

SUBSEQUENT TURNS OMITTED, NO RELEVANT INFO

</body>
</html>

Posted: **16 Apr 2019, 19:39**

Beta: Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God's +1 is bugged. Once all cards are exiled from opponents hands, no permanents are exiled anymore. At least, the computer were able to choose the already exiled permanents as targets for being exiled again. Hence, nothing happened upon using his +1, except for draw a card. Only the log stated that the same 3 permanents were exiled by my 3 opponents, every time I used his +1 ability.

In addition, the gamelog seems to be bugged. Whenever Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God's +1 ability was used, the gamelog wrote my name down, as if I had chosen a card to exile. That is why the following gamelog looks quite weird.

| Open: 1st activation of his +1, every computer had several cards in hand

21:08: Hoac
activates: You draw a card. Each opponent exiles a card from their hand or
a permanent they control. from <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a]
21:08: Hoac
draws a card
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Vraska, Relic Seeker">Vraska,
Relic Seeker</a> [833] from hand to the exile
zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Jace, the Mind Sculptor">Jace,
the Mind Sculptor</a> [7c1] from hand to the
exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Teferi, Hero of Dominaria">Teferi,
Hero of Dominaria</a> [833] from hand to the
exile zone

My opponents exiled the three cards above, I only drew one card.

21:08: Hoac
activates: exile target permanent you own. Return that card to the
battlefield under your control. from <a href="#Aminatou, the Fateshifter">Aminatou,
the Fateshifter</a> [176] targeting <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a] 
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a] from battlefield to
the exile zone
21:08: Hoac
puts <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a] from exile zone
onto the Battlefield

2nd activation of his +1

21:08: Hoac
activates: You draw a card. Each opponent exiles a card from their hand or
a permanent they control. from <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a]
21:08: Hoac
draws a card
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Teferi, Temporal Archmage">Teferi,
Temporal Archmage</a> [0a3] from hand to the
exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Teferi, Temporal Archmage">Teferi,
Temporal Archmage</a> [e7c] from hand to the
exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Demonic Tutor">Demonic Tutor</a>
[abf] from hand to the exile zone

3rd

21:08: Hoac
activates: You draw a card. Each opponent exiles a card from their hand or
a permanent they control. from <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a]
21:08: Hoac
draws a card
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Ajani Steadfast">Ajani
Steadfast</a> [616] from hand to the exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Jace, Cunning Castaway">Jace,
Cunning Castaway</a> [05b] from hand to the
exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Merciless Eviction">Merciless
Eviction</a> [751] from hand to the exile zone

4th (Below, Bayou and Tropical Island were exiled for the first time)

21:08: Hoac
activates: You draw a card. Each opponent exiles a card from their hand or
a permanent they control. from <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a]
21:08: Hoac
draws a card
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Dack Fayden">Dack Fayden</a>
[7ca] from hand to the exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Bayou">Bayou</a>
[cab] from battlefield to the exile zone
21:08: Hoac
moves <a href="#Tropical Island">Tropical
Island</a> [d9b] from battlefield to the exile
zone

5th Bayou and Tropical Island were chosen as targets for the exile effect, although they were already in exile.

21:10: Hoac
activates: You draw a card. Each opponent exiles a card from their hand or
a permanent they control. from <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a]
21:10: Hoac
draws a card
21:10: Hoac
moves <a href="#The Chain Veil">The Chain Veil</a>
[148] from hand to the exile zone
21:10: Hoac
moves <a href="#Bayou">Bayou</a>
[cab] from exile zone to the exile zone
21:10: Hoac
moves <a href="#Tropical Island">Tropical
Island</a> [d9b] from exile zone to the exile
zone

6th Now the third computer exiled its last card, "Interplanar Beacon". Throughout all following activations of Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God's +1 ability, the 3 computer enemies chose Interplanar Beacon, Bayou, and Tropical Island as targets for the exile effect. Even though they were already in exile.

21:10: Hoac
activates: You draw a card. Each opponent exiles a card from their hand or
a permanent they control. from <a href="#Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God">Nicol
Bolas, Dragon-God</a> [f1a]
21:10: Hoac
draws a card
21:10: Hoac
moves <a href="#Interplanar Beacon">Interplanar
Beacon</a> [ebe] from battlefield to the exile
zone
21:10: Hoac
moves <a href="#Bayou">Bayou</a>
[cab] from exile zone to the exile zone
21:10: Hoac
moves <a href="#Tropical Island">Tropical
Island</a> [d9b] from exile zone to the exile
zone

Fixed in the next release.

Posted: **17 Apr 2019, 16:27**

I control Seedborn Muse and Mist of Stagnation

During opponent's A upkeep I casted Time Stop and then it moved to opponent Bs turn and my stuff didn't untap.

Posted: **18 Apr 2019, 05:32**

When Temporal Aperture reveals a land card, its not possible to play that land card.

Fixed in the next release.

Posted: **18 Apr 2019, 20:51**

I casted Beacon of Unrest targeting opponent's Purphoros. When it spell resolved purphoros was placed under opponents control and not mine.

Opponent had previously played Brand so maybe that has something to do with it (several turns prior)

I have an extremely strong feeling that is the reason. The effect last "indefinitely".

Posted: **20 Apr 2019, 08:42**

Beta: There are two issues with Ugin, the Ineffable.

His +1 puts a spirit token onto the battlefield, but the draw triggers instantly, once the token enters the battlefield. If the token leaves the battlefield (later on) nothing happens or triggers anymore, because you already drew the card belonging to the token.

Ugin's -3 ability is "destroy target permanent", instead of "destroy target permanent that's one or more colors".

Fixed in the next release.

Posted: **21 Apr 2019, 16:33**

Grave Upheaval is able to target planeswalkers.

Fixed in the next release.

Collectible Card Game Headquarters

Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE

Re: Bug Reports XMage 1.4.34 SOFTWARE