BUG Report: Sisay is considered as a 5 colors card!

by **wwwmagnottait** » 09 Apr 2024, 14:13

Hi all! Sisay, Weatherlight Captain is considered as a 5 colors card, even when you start the game and Sisay is in the Command Zone. Bloom Tender can consequently procude all 5 mana colors.

The weird thing is that Sisay, on XMage deck editor, is correctly considered as a white only permanent.

The same, identical issue happens when, for example, I copy with Sakashima another single color creature but with an activated ability with all colors (as Go-Shintai of life's origin). As you can see in the image below, it is considered of all colors, and Bloom Tender gives all 5 mana.

This issue is present on Xmage since 2019 and never solved...can anyone help? Many thanks

by **wwwmagnottait** » 10 Apr 2024, 08:51

: as u can see Bloom Tender gives ALL 5 mana colors

: In Deck Editor, instead, Sisay is correctly considered as a white only permanent

by **chpaltry** » 03 Jun 2024, 07:17

t sounds like XMage isn't correctly handling the color identity of cards with abilities that produce multiple colors. Hopefully, someone with coding experience can address this bug soon.

by **Ninja058** » 26 Aug 2024, 22:29

The issue is that in the editor it's only considered white, right? I ask this because, for commander, colors in ruletext count towards identity.

by **Marilynbooth** » 29 Oct 2024, 01:36

Ninja058 wrote:The issue is that in the editor it's only considered white, right? I ask this because, for commander, colors in ruletext count towards identity.

If a card is colored in the rules text but is shown as white in the editor, does this affect Commander deck building?

by **Sherccarty** » 22 Nov 2024, 09:22

wwwmagnottait wrote: Monkey Mart said:Hi all! Sisay, Weatherlight Captain is considered as a 5 colors card, even when you start the game and Sisay is in the Command Zone. Bloom Tender can consequently procude all 5 mana colors.

The weird thing is that Sisay, on XMage deck editor, is correctly considered as a white only permanent.

The same, identical issue happens when, for example, I copy with Sakashima another single color creature but with an activated ability with all colors (as Go-Shintai of life's origin). As you can see in the image below, it is considered of all colors, and Bloom Tender gives all 5 mana.

This issue is present on Xmage since 2019 and never solved...can anyone help? Many thanks

Hopefully, a coder can fix this bug soon!