Manalink Update July 22

[Cognis]

If you autotap for mana with Eldrazi Temple and an eldrazi clone with summoning sickness you might encounter sort of a bug. Let's say you want to play Ulamog's Crusher for 8 mana. You have Eldrazi Temple, Eye of Ugin, another land and three clones, one with summoning sickness you have enough mana to play the card, but if you use the autotap you can't sacrifice the clone with summoning sickness and when you press cancel you are one mana short since the tapped Eldrazi Temple doesn't register the second mana for the eldrazi. This is more of a warning to be careful if playing eldrazi then a bug but if thought about reporting it.

[Cognis]

All Is Dust doesn't make you sacrifice coloured tokens like from Bitterblossom or Garruk Wildspeaker.

[Cognis]

When All Is Dust is played and the opponent has Kitchen Finks the get sacrificed and come back into play. Shouldn't they be sacrificed again because they come back into play while the spell is in effect. I don't know if it's an error or not since I'm not sure on the rules.

[Cognis]

One more thing. Vindicate just destroyed Ulamog, the Infinite Gyre which should be indestructible.

[scherbchen1]

When All Is Dust is played and the opponent has Kitchen Finks the get sacrificed and come back into play. Shouldn't they be sacrificed again because they come back into play while the spell is in effect. I don't know if it's an error or not since I'm not sure on the rules.

not sure how you could argue that seeing as All is Dust is not a continuous effect. all coloured permanents get "sacrifice this permanent" rather than there being an effect that reads "for the remainder of the turn all coloured permanents etc etc". that "sac me!" gets resolved. anything new that comes into play does not have "sacrifice this permanent".

[Cognis]

But All Is Dust says that players sacrifice all coloured permanents. I think it works this way.

If you have Kitchen Finks you sacrifice them and the spell plays out so when you get persisted Kitchen Finks you don't have to sacrifice it.

If you have two Kitchen Finks when you sacrifice the first you get one persisted and one normal which leaves with one persited Kitchen Finks.

What I don't know is should all permanents be sacrificed or does the last persistent permanent stay like Kitchen Finks or saproling tokens from Sprouting Thrinax.

[discoransom]

Finks should persist with All is Dust, the same exact way it does with lethal damage, an edict spell, or a Wrath. The permanents are all sacrificed at the same time, then they are put into the graveyard one at a time. Then the persist effect takes place- after the spell has fully resolved and all creatures have been sacrificed. Once all permanents have been sacced, All is Dust has completed its job and doesn't see the creatures coming back into play.

[monopoman]

All of them are sacrificed at the same moment then the spell is resolved. Finks will come back with a counter on it period.

[Cognis]

That's right, they do get sacrificed at the same time, I forgot about that.

[aww1979]

When I hardcast Artisan of Kozilek, I wasn't able to bring back my Ulamog's Crusher in the grave.

[gabeiq]

I don't know if here is the right place to complain but Exalted from Sigiled Paladin isn't working.

[stassy]

I don't know if here is the right place to complain but Exalted from Sigiled Paladin isn't working.

I can confirm the effect is not working.

[jatill]

Updated version is available now. Exalted, All is Dust, and Atrisan are fixed. Conundrum Sphinx is added (albeit with lo-res art).

[maverick09]

Hi,

Just wondering if this Update is compatible with Huggybaby's Microprose Magic the Gathering 2010 Custom Installer ISO?(viewtopic.php?f=15&t=2349)

Will the new cards also be available in Shandalar?

Also, does this update also include your Manalink Update posted in June, or will I need to apply both the June and July updates to get all the new cards?

Btw, many thanks for the great development work!

[stassy]

No, the only updates compatibles with the custom installer ISO lies within the thread you posted.

No new cards are currently available in Shandalar.

To install the latest version, you need to create another magic folder different from the ISO and follow the instructions in the wiki :
http://www.slightlymagic.net/wiki/Installation