[fixed/closed]Archangel of Thune

[RanDomino]

Describe the Bug:
Part 1- Because Archangel adds the counter immediately, creatures that are dealt exactly lethal damage in combat instead survive. For example, if you attack with Archangel and a 4/4, and the opponent blocks your 4/4 with a 4/2, your 4/4 will survive combat with an additional +1/+1 counter and four damage assigned.

Part 2- Multiple Archangels don't seem to be adding multiple counters for each instance of gaining life; you only get one counter on each of your creatures, not one counter for each Archangel.

In the screenshot, both bugs are shown- the tapped Archangel attacked last turn, putting a counter on each of my creatures; this turn I played the second Archangel and attacked with the creatures which are tapped in the picture, and the Accorder Paladin blocked the Fleecemane Lion (non-monstrous).

Which card did behave improperly ?
Archangel of Thune

Which update are you using?(date,name)Which type(Duel,Gauntlet,Sealed Deck)
Journey into Nyx

What exactly should be the correct behavior/interaction ?
Part 1- the counters should not be added immediately, but after at least one SBE-check to ensure that creatures dealt lethal damage in combat do not survive due to getting the +1/+1 counter.
Part 2- Each Archangel should add a +1/+1 counter to each creature for each instance of lifegain.

Are any other cards possibly affected by this bug ?
Mephidross Vampire

[Gargaroz]

Fixed in 38e6956

[BAgate]

multiple copies stack correctly

death isn't checked for before counters. Ex. An Archangel of Thune attacks and is blocked by an Air Elemental. the Archangel of Thune is dealt 4 damage and should die before it gets counters, but it gets the counters first.

[Aswan jaguar]

Your last post about another bug with lethal damage reminded me of this bug.
Korath have you fixed this for shandalar (Archangel of Thune of getting counters before lethal damage applies)?

[Korath]

No, it's broken there too.

[Gargaroz]

Fixed in 0fa89a0