[still bugged]Bug using Chord of Calling

[Grinerdam]

God morning,

I have facing trouble with Chord of Calling. The card seens not to work properly. Rather randomly working. Sometimes it works and sometimes don't.
If I cast it using just convoke, or just normal mana or even with both, my library is opened and when I choose a creature with the CMC equal or less the X the creature just don't comes into play and the spell is wasted most of the times. And when it works I don't know why.

See the pictures below demonstrating this step by step.

[BAgate]

Convoke was broken, but has been fixed in dev. I don't know if this specific issue was fixed though...

[Korath]

If you can find a consistent repro I can test dev. The "Select a creature card with CMC [whatever] or less" prompt should be a reliable indicator of whether the determination at casting is accurate, without having to experiment with tutoring different creatures.

[Aswan jaguar]

1- You use convoke tap 3 green creatures and then pay 4 mana for X value (value is shown as 0 in open library prompt) and you select Masked Admirers they don't come into play.
2- You use convoke tap 2 green creatures and then pay G and 4 mana for X value (value is shown as 0 in open library prompt) and you select Masked Admirers they don't come into play.
3- You play the spell normally GGG and 4 mana for X value (value is shown as 0 in open library prompt) and you select Masked Admirers they don't come into play.

The only time I made it work was when I paid GGG with convoke tapping 3 green creatures then used convoke and tapped 4 colourless creatures when the last was tapped (the prompt that counts mana opened but for X showed 0) but then I cancelledhit done and library prompt opened with the correct amount for X=4 and when I selected Masked Admirers they came into play.

[Korath]

Current status:

1. Debug three green creatures onto the bf (I used Aboroth)
2. Debug or play four non- -producing lands onto the bf (I used a mix of Plains and Island)
3. Debug Cunning Wish into hand; cast it for Chord of Calling
4. Cast Chord of Calling, tap all three creatures to pay for , tap all four lands for .

Prompt says "Select a creature card with CMC 1 or less" (and I didn't check that that's what it actually tutors for, but the code looks like it matches). Expected: "...CMC 4 or less".

If there's at least one creature tapped to pay for the part, it works properly.

Fixed this case in d152ccc.

Convoke uses an entirely different codepath when player1 (the AI in single-player, the remote player in multiplayer) is paying the cost. I haven't investigated how well that works in single-player at all. It breaks multiplayer, of course.

[BAgate]

In single player it works fine for human player, but for AI it works fine when cast normally, but if convoke is used it summons a card with CMC of 1 or less.

[Gargaroz]

Already fixed in dev.

[Aswan jaguar]

Manalink dev 778ccb5 version:
Everything seems fine when convoke is used.
If you select to pay the cost manually and don't have green untapped creatures in play everything is fine.
However if you select to pay the cost manually and you have green untapped creatures then you are prompt to pay if you pay GGG and 4 for X you will have to fetch a 1 cmc card (the cost in this prompt is not counted correctly - it is coded to check correctly only the green mana cost).
If in this first prompt you pay manually only the green cost and hit done then you are prompt again if you want to pay manually or convoke if you select manually (or convoke) and then pay the cost it works fine.