Bug Reports for Magarena 1.74

[melvin]

To help us in addressing bugs, the best way is to create an issue on the issue tracker. This lets us keep track each report separately and ensures it doesn't get lost.
https://github.com/magarena/magarena/issues (requires github account)

For game play bugs, please include a gameplay report zip file. You can create a gameplay report by opening the options menu (press Esc during a duel) and selecting the "Gameplay Report" menu item.

Less preferred is to post your report in this thread. (requires forum account)

You can report anonymously via gitreports, note that name/email if provided will be listed on the issue tracker.
https://gitreports.com/issue/magarena/magarena (no sign-up required, name/email optional)

[jerichopumpkin]

AI equipped Gate Smasher to one of my creatures.

Edit: since AI wasn't satisfied, it changed the creature from Colossodon Yearling to One Of The Pack and back again during the following turns

[melvin]

AI equipped Gate Smasher to one of my creatures.

Edit: since AI wasn't satisfied, it changed the creature from Colossodon Yearling to One Of The Pack and back again during the following turns

Good find! For a second there I thought it is a AI misplay rather than a bug. Would be good to mention what is the expected behavior, i.e. Equipment cannot be put on opponent's creatures.

Tracking as https://github.com/magarena/magarena/issues/794

[jerichopumpkin]

Good find! For a second there I thought it is a AI misplay rather than a bug. Would be good to mention what is the expected behavior, i.e. Equipment cannot be put on opponent's creatures.

Tracking as https://github.com/magarena/magarena/issues/794

Sorry, next time I'll add the expected behaviour and/or the rule reference.
By the way, I've not tested this, but I think that the problem is related to the condition to equip on Gate Crasher (only creature with Thoughness 4+), since that never occurred before with any other equipment

[melvin]

By the way, I've not tested this, but I think that the problem is related to the condition to equip on Gate Crasher (only creature with Thoughness 4+), since that never occurred before with any other equipment

You are right on the mark. This bug is only for the new equip with restriction. I forgot to add in the "you control" part. The default equip uses "creature you control" to select target so it was not affected, the new one allows a custom selector such as "creature with toughness 4 or greater" but the full selector should be "creature with toughness 4 or greater you control". The "you control" is not in the card text but it needs to be added in by the engine.

[jerichopumpkin]

more a AI strange behaviour than a bug: AI played Mystic Meditation, then choose to discrd two cards instead of a creature. The chosen cards are both creature cards. Only a reanimator deck would justify that choice, but that is not the case.

[melvin]

more a AI strange behaviour than a bug...

Thanks for bringing it up, unfortunately the information provided is not sufficient to reproduce the play. The screenshot is a nice touch, but we can't see the AI's hand and library. There is a much better mechanism now, the gameplay report. It includes a snapshot file which we can directly open in-game to the exact state without manually recreating the game state from the screenshot.

As described in the first post,

For game play bugs, please include a gameplay report zip file. You can create a gameplay report by opening the options menu (press Esc during a duel) and selecting the "Gameplay Report" menu item.